@TheMitrusa yea I know , actually I never wanted to make videos but I wanted to find some videos as soon as I realized that there are no middle easterners who are interested in it & I as soon as I saw that there are no videos, I felt obligated to learn it for myself & to show all middl easterners the language of the canaanites (language of the carthaginians, phoenicians, classic canaanites) ,I wanted especially find people of tunisia and lebanon and palestinie & syria to remember their roots
@Malkibaal It doesnt really sound much like Arabic, although I can understand some words. Shams fi.. Punic is extremely close to Hebrew though, i sounds just like it. Are the two languages closely related someow?
@shnoepie1 Where do I claim that it should sound arabic? do you want to throw false claims and assertions at me, which I never claimed? Punic is the daughter language of phoenician-canaanite, phoenician-canaanite language is the language of the canaanites which survived the and hyksos , they were called phoenicians by the greeks ., the phoenician-canaanite language is branch of the canaanit language hebrew language is also a canaanite language
@Malkibaal it is a semitic sound, and TheMitrusa realize thisbut he just knows arabic having semitic sounds, so he jumped to the conclusion that it sounds like arabic, it sounds actually semitic, not arabic, but arabic preserved many semitic features :)
I understood what was said and its interesting that in Semitic languages, one can immediately recognize what's said - only thing is sometimes I guess the vowels are added or taken away... :D
just amazing and some words are close to arabic ^^
TheMitrusa 3 months ago
@TheMitrusa yea I know , actually I never wanted to make videos but I wanted to find some videos as soon as I realized that there are no middle easterners who are interested in it & I as soon as I saw that there are no videos, I felt obligated to learn it for myself & to show all middl easterners the language of the canaanites (language of the carthaginians, phoenicians, classic canaanites) ,I wanted especially find people of tunisia and lebanon and palestinie & syria to remember their roots
Malkibaal 3 months ago
@Malkibaal It doesnt really sound much like Arabic, although I can understand some words. Shams fi.. Punic is extremely close to Hebrew though, i sounds just like it. Are the two languages closely related someow?
shnoepie1 3 months ago
@shnoepie1 Where do I claim that it should sound arabic? do you want to throw false claims and assertions at me, which I never claimed? Punic is the daughter language of phoenician-canaanite, phoenician-canaanite language is the language of the canaanites which survived the and hyksos , they were called phoenicians by the greeks ., the phoenician-canaanite language is branch of the canaanit language hebrew language is also a canaanite language
Malkibaal 3 months ago
@Malkibaal it is a semitic sound, and TheMitrusa realize thisbut he just knows arabic having semitic sounds, so he jumped to the conclusion that it sounds like arabic, it sounds actually semitic, not arabic, but arabic preserved many semitic features :)
Malkibaal 3 months ago
I understood what was said and its interesting that in Semitic languages, one can immediately recognize what's said - only thing is sometimes I guess the vowels are added or taken away... :D
SefaradiTal 6 months ago 2
@SefaradiTal thanks for your openness and understanding :)
Malkibaal 6 months ago