Three Kingdoms MV9 - Zhuge Liang / Lu Yi [ 三国 - 诸葛亮 / 陆毅 ]
Uploader Comments (DashSSlove)
All Comments (20)
-
What a shame the movie is not available in the United States! :.. (
-
@kanraga ^____^ I have not problem with the fact that you expected something more touching. I just want to say MVs cannot be as touching, nor complete, as to watch the whole series anyway ^^. MVs are just a way to express what kind of feelings the maker had for him the moment the MVs is created. There is no way an MV with limited capacity can describe perfectly the character. And of course, why do you think I would feel discouraged ^^ ? Thanks for passing by.
-
@kanraga Red Cliffs has nicer cinematographic shots, that's why I used them ^^, coz I wanted to have, like you said, a rather "cool" MV for Lu Yi. I have not used other movies until before this MV. But I don't think Red Cliffs have anything more symbolist like you said. Red Cliffs was made as a blocbuster and did not , at all, have the deepness that San Guo 2010 has. And you know, not only Red Cliffs, In this MV, there are shots from Heros and Flying Daggers too ^^ ! Thanks for your comments
-
Maybe scrapbook was the effect you were going for, in which case feel free to ignore this. I simply wish there had been more to this MV than simply a good song and a selection of shots - chosen right, it's possible to tell a very moving story about the life and growth of Lu Yi's Zhuge Liang, and you did seem to have some parallels between his younger self and older selves in there. It's too bad it wasn't enough, I guess.
Don't let this be discouraging, though - keep working at it!
-
As for the video itself:
While I agree that Lu Yi's portrayal of Zhuge Liang is indeed touching and easy to empathize with (and I am personally a fan), I felt that this MV could have been more coherent. You selected a lot of shots in which Zhuge Liang happened to look cool, but there was very little sense of a unified story or theme that could have been told through them, and as such it felt more like a scrapbook of shots than a properly moving montage.
what is the title and artist of this song?
xiuqing22 1 month ago
@xiuqing22 : hi sorry for answering too late. I did not see your question. This song is by Chen Kun, and this is the ending of a series called "The Conquest" !!!! ^^
DashSSlove 1 week ago
Can you really? Where would you go about buying it? I've been a fan of Three Kingdoms and of Zhuge Liang since I was in 7th Grade. I appriciate your help! :)
oldpang 1 month ago
@oldpang : You can buy the DVDs with sub via taobao or yesasia.com ! ^^ cheers !
DashSSlove 1 week ago
There were quite a few spliced shots from John Woo's Red Cliff movie in there. I'm not against this - it makes things more cinematic, since Three Kingdoms doesn't have nearly as much attempted symbolism as Red Cliffs does - but it's something I thought deserves mention.
kanraga 2 months ago
@kanraga : ah, may I ask, why do you think we should mention Red Cliff ? I mean, don't you think people will surely know there are Red Cliff, Heroes, and Flying Dagger's shots here ? I just thought people would naturally recognise all of them. Unless there is a copyright or credit problem, I don't realy understand why you would want to specifically mention Red Cliff ! ^__^
Best !
DashSSlove 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos