Top Comments
All Comments (1,111)
-
I cryed reading this chapter!!!!!!! XD
-
i think that them breaking up was FAR to much. he should have atLEAST brought her with him and changed her. (soiler alert is you havin read the 4th book-->) in the 4th book he changes her anyway? i cried. it was just so sadd. this is my least fav chaper because it is just so sad. )':
-
edward and bella breaking up is so sad and edward was too harsh.
-
i cried sooooo much
-
hey can someone tell me how bella feels in this chapter? Please message me if you can explain and if you want I'll give you the reason I need to know....much appreciated to anyone who answers.
-
i was bawling my eyes out. so sad. and how he loves her so much its breathtakinggg!!<3 i read the dark side of the moon from edwards p.o.v its really amazing. i loove edward & bellaaa!!
-
I still can't get enough of New Moon....especially Taylorz transformation
-
of couse edward was way to harsh on bella. you would know this becasuse of the ending in new moon. edward says he regrets breaking up and will never leave her side until she orders her away.
-
Yea he was a little harsh about taking the stuff away.But she did do it to protect her though we got to remembe that
-
dont think he should have done it over the phone but i might have been better if he told her simply that he found someone else and just left. it would have worked and realize she could move on with jake.



i cried the whole time i love edward
smileymiley497 2 years ago 6
It was a harsh time for me too, when Edward left her.. saying "you are not enough" ....a depressing moment, but his eyes were saying the contrary... he was just fighting his feelings... I cried as well... awful!!!
sanmajesty 1 year ago 5