Link to this comment:
Uploader Comments (musanim)
All Comments (21)
-
It intrigues and facsinates me. I do not know if I would call it good, or bad, but I think the program certainly makes it more easy to understand. listening to this without the visual aid feels like putting your head underwater and trying to understand a foreign language, while listening with the aid feels like just trying to understand a foreign language. With the visual aid, I can see the structure, almost feel and see how it sounds. Kudos to you.
Paticula1135 2 months ago
-
@musanim Yup. It just doesn't make sense. it was short and simple. What more could you ask for?
PianoDude1011 9 months ago
-
Awe, you should have written more!
Well, short and sweet, I guess.
Hopefully next time we get a sixteen minute epic~
Iemanonymous1 1 year ago
-
@19ZeldaLover95 If "sense" comes from tonality, then it makes no sense. If "sense" comes from other features (e.g. imitation) then it makes as much sense as any piece of contrapuntal music.
musanim 1 year ago
5:05
Debussy, First Arabesque (piano solo, animation version 3)by musanim49,657 views
6:27
Chopin, Nocturne, opus 27 #2, piano solo (animated interval graphic), ver 2by musanim63,206 views
5:05
Debussy, First Arabesque (piano solo, animation version 1)by musanim17,713 views
0:50
A Stone's Throwby musanim4,248 views
5:50
Bach, Brandenburg Concerto #6, 1st mvt. (animation ver. 3)by musanim1,690 views
4:29
Hardest song on piano ever! (Circus Galop)by charmander121222,575,460 views
5:15
Bach, Brandenburg Concerto #4, 3rd mvt., presto (bar-graph score)by musanim77,694 views
2:03
Bach, Fugue 7 in E-flat major, WTC Book 2, BWV 876, animated scoreby smalin75,689 views
5:39
Handel, Hallelujah Chorus (version 2)by musanim37,905 views
4:07
Mozart, Marriage of Figaro, overture (bar-graph score)by musanim119,874 views
3:15
Bach, Jesu, Joy of Man's Desiring, from Cantata 147 (sung by alien robots)by smalin147,427 views
6:01
Trio for Harp, Flute, and Oboe, No 2by WizardWalk11,468 views
4:08
Christmas Light Show - Hallelujah Chorusby websitedave3,160 views
3:43
Debussy Valse Romantiqueby MagicDonDino332,723 views
2:03
Bach, Fugue in E-flat major, WTC Book 2, BWV 876, bar-graph scoreby musanim16,776 views
1:39
Chopin's Op.25 No.6 'Thirds' Etude Audio + Sheet Musicby tomekkobialka20,501 views
5:42
Bach, Brandenburg Concerto #6, 1st mvt. (animation ver. 1)by musanim3,294 views
5:50
Bach, Brandenburg Concerto #6, 1st mvt. (animation ver. 4)by musanim4,741 views
5:50
Bach, Brandenburg Concerto #6, first movement (animation ver. 4)by smalin106,275 views
- Loading more suggestions...
it sounds like a big fail
Nakato5 1 month ago
@Nakato5 Actually, this is an intelligence test masquerading as a piece of music.
musanim 1 month ago
Being my third time listening to this (each time in a different video version), and again being confronted with the (puzzling) dissatisfaction of so many commenters, I'd like to pose this simple, or perhaps complex, question... what makes music good? Is it the aesthetic quality (being whether or not a person enjoys hearing/listening to it), or is it structure, and form? Is it both? Neither? Is that even a valid question? Perhaps I should be asking what makes something music instead of sound...
siliconface 4 months ago
@siliconface No simple answer to your question has been found.
musanim 4 months ago
and over half of the people disliked it?!
PianoDude1011 9 months ago
@PianoDude1011 For me, that's a record.
musanim 9 months ago