Scientific Genesis: 2. Origin of the Solar System (1975)
Uploader Comments (omatumr)
All Comments (17)
-
@artynz watch it again and listen this time...also read, if you can follow, the facts are what is presented here in a very clear way for you to research it further ---- even stating that these findings go against the previously accepted norm......geeesh, you also need a bowling-ball-sized meteor to hit you in the head, a.s.a.p.!
-
@RigelKentaurusA when you don't understandd something, the best thing to do is to learn about it before you criticize and show your ignorance. Also such lack of respect shows some kind of serious self-loathing, under-developed puny human -----> may a bowling-ball-sized meteor strike you in the head. this is a presentation of the facts, so, either get to studying or STFU. have a crappy day anus.
-
I totally agree with professor Manuel he is a very good thinker and wise man.
-
man this sucks, all you guys say is who is wrong and who is right.
i dont care who is wrong or right, space is still epic :D
-
"I have a PhD in nuclear chemistry... and space science."
Is in *direct* conflict with
"... neutron repulsion..."
"The sun is made mostly of iron" and that there's a neutron star in the sun.
What a nut.
-
Iron is the most common element in the earth and meteorites. However it is well down the list for the Sun (you got this wrong). Hydrogen and Helium are the dominant substances in the Sun.
Personal attacks are childish. Please address the experimental data:
"Attraction and repulsion of nucleons: Sources of stellar energy", J. Fusion Energy 19, 93-98 (2001).
"Composition of the solar interior: Information from isotope ratios", ESA SP-517, pp. 345-348 (2003).
"The Sun is a plasma diffuser that sorts atoms by mass", Physics of Atomic Nuclei 69, 1847-1856 (2006)
omatumr 1 year ago
Artynz.
Hydrogen (H) is element #1, the lightest of all elements.
Helium (He) is element #2, the next lightest element.
The photosphere, the top of the Sun's atmosphere, is 91% H and 9% He .
Why? The Sun is a plasma diffuser that sorts atoms by mass.
See the data here: "The Sun is a plasma diffuser that sorts atoms by mass", Physics of Atomic Nuclei 69 (2006) 1847-1856; Yadernaya Fizika 69, number 11, (Nov 2006)
omatumr 1 year ago
Thanks for the reply, Doctor Manuel. The Xenon is strange only because it isn't the isotope found locally.
Could the same be said for the (relative) abundance of Helium 3 on Earth's Moon, compared to Earth?
IShootist 1 year ago
@IShootist Yes.
Values calculated for the "Age of the Universe" - from isotope ratios of Th and U on planet Earth - is one of the most unrealistic stories of modern science!
Continuously accumulated flaws will eventually sink even the best-funded ship, as has started to happen to the “Ship of Global Warming.” Other ships in the fleet are being dragged down too.
See Physics World comments today on APS support of the sinking “Ship of Global Warming”
omatumr 1 year ago
The use of the term 'strange' for the xenon isotope is confusing at first read, unless you are suggesting that the Xe-2 isotope is Strange Matter? Probably not, since the existence of Strange Matter would cause all the other matter it came in contact with to become Strange as well.
IShootist 1 year ago
@IShootist
Earth accounts for about 0.003% of the mass of the Solar System. But isotope abundances here are "normal" by definition.
Jupiter is ~318 times more massive that Earth, but its xenon is "strange", with about twice the "normal" abundance of Xe-136.
omatumr 1 year ago