Sensorium (eeeteee No Grunt Symphonic Edit) - Epica
Top Comments
All Comments (13)
-
NO EPICA Grunts? this is the worst I've seen a fan of this band.
If you like Epica, you like it for some reason
Epica will be without Simon (there was a tour without she, with Amanda)
Epica will not be without Mark and his Grunts, Cause Epica Grunts are very distinctive.
Simon has been losing a lot of songs that do not like to sing well.
Sin los gruñidos de Mark, esto sería como Evanescense!
Aprendan a aceptar a las bandas asi como son
-
I've got a sneaking suspicion that they utilised 'grunts' as a way of marking them apart from Nightwish.
Without them they would sound more 'mainstream' - but wouldn't that improve their popularity?! Yes?/No?
If they're prepared to release 'no-grunt' versions themselves, then they're obviously reacting to some backlash...
-
i do believe a well done grunt is BEAUTIFUL however a ballad version is just as lovely and they dont have to be the same my problem with most grunters is they sound like they have a cat stuck in their throat! but epica is good both ways and i dont mind and obviously the band dont either cause they did some no grunt versions themselves!
-
wow my reaction at listening to this song really amazed me. When I started to listen to Epica I just dealed with the grunts as a price to pay for the beautiful music and simone's beautiful voice, but now that i heard this version I really feel that something is missing... I thought I was going to like this one better... Well now I understand the position of Epica fans that support the beautiful female vocals/death grunts duality and complementation of each other :P
-
| "I deal with the grunts, but I don't like them. The band sounds so much better without them." |
Yeah I agree, songs like Force of the Shore and Consign to Oblivion (Age of Dawns pt3) could really do without the grunts...imo D:
-
Hm... Mark is not really the best grunter out there imo, and I am not like "there must be grunts or else" or anything like that... but this vid convinced me that the "antitheses"-part (or whatever it's called) with the grunts/oboe dóes seem to provide this song with a bit of very important spicing: I like this version less then the original, and that kind of surprised me.
So thanks for uploading NGE, this actually had educational value :)
-
You don't Like Epica
You like Simone
-
This song is better live!!!
-
Because of the grunts i must take this song to Gothic Metal in my mp3^^ lol for me it doesnt matter if there were grunts or not but nice alternative version of the songs but i do not like to delete the grunt better to place a clear male voice instead
I deal with the grunts, but I don't like them. The band sounds so much better without them.
inkenyo 3 years ago 8
Good job, IMO you improved the song vastly. I'm sorry but I see no musical value in adding grunts to these songs.
Tronman63 4 years ago 7