Collectivism/Anarcho-Communism - Planned Chaos
Uploader Comments (mikeshanklin)
Top Comments
-
@anarcrustie If I build a tractor, but I am not a farmer, that means I cannot use it nor can I sell it? Why would anyone, except a farmer, then, build a tractor? What if the farmer is busy running a farm and does not have time to build a tractor? Does that mean all farm production will be done by hand?
Video Responses
All Comments (2,039)
-
the central failure of the argument presented here is based on the assumption that human nature is inherently egoistic and barbaric. the truth is that humans have predispositions for both violence and egotism AND for peace, solidarity, and altruism. whether one or the other is activated depends on environmental factors. anarchist communism seeks also to establish the right conditions that can enable the positive potentials of humanity.
-
Look at all the bawww from collectivists in the comments.
Hilarious!
-
Excellent!
-
Shitty video! Its best without audio, i recommend looking at the pictures and coming to your own conclusion (anarcho-com rulez!)
-
Eh, stop contradicting yourself, capitalist moron.
-
You don't understand what you're talking about.
-
@turbofritz2 i am not an anarcho communist. but it is true that communist russia had a large state, thats a part of the communism. anarchy have no state, thats also true. so yes, this is the end of the story.
-
@nerdomaniac You anarcho communist are contradicting yourself.
Communist russia had an extremly strong state. Communism is centralization witch is always dangerous because a dictator can take control easier.
Communism is full state power. Anarchy is no state power. End of story.
-
@mikeshanklin voluntarism is very important also when there is a shortage of stuff people act like animals doesn't matter who you are when your life is on the line you know what your capable of. People are more important than stuff, i am no anarcho- communist, but central planing can work, also democracy wont( you can do whatever you want as long as it doesn't hurt anyone else). also nobody owns anything but you can use anything if there is enough apples you wont trade apples get what i mean?
-
@mikeshanklin hm... it is very interesting what you advocate : Anarcho capitalist- The state if violence and insanity( I agree), Free market capitalism will raise the standard of living for all( lol hm... we will see about that lol). No country is an island there for we are all locked in, so the American government is here to balance the power with Russia, China, Britain. Do you know most people are ignorant? around the world that is. intelligent people don't need rulers only leaders(voluntary)
anarchism + communism = anarcho-communism.
anarchism is against the state.
communism is against capitalism.
so to form a anarcho-communistic place, you have remove both the state and capitalism and the idea that people can "own" something. so in theory with anarcho-communism there is no state and nobody owns anything. there is no police, no military , no dictators, president or council or any other form of state. it will be a lot like anarchism, except people cant own stuff.
nerdomaniac 1 month ago
@nerdomaniac So no one can produce anything? To produce something, like paper, one must first chop down a tree. What if someone else is using that tree? Who gets to control the tree? The first or the second person wanting to use it? Why even work if everything I make can just be taken from me? Might as well not save up for retirement, no food as everyone will just take mine instead of doing the harder thing and working. Who gets to control/own the tree in my earlier question? Who decides?
mikeshanklin 1 month ago 11