Uploaded by MusicalDudeMayhem on Sep 24, 2008
Make up your own minds, but this is how I see it:
Glamour: GA win hands down, but that's kinda their thang. Tiffany wasn't going for glamour, so fans of the natural-looking woman will be somewhat warmed by the down-to-Earth way Tiffany presented herself.
Vocals: I don't think there's much to call between Nadine and Tiffany. In terms of the tracks, as a whole, Tiffany displays the greatest vocal range, but she also slips up a bit, managing to sound intermittently moronic (check the end of the vid!) so I'm gonna call it even here.
Making the song their own: both GA and Tiffany's version is a cover. However, Tiffany's energetic sound and the track struck the perfect notes for its time and produced a massive, arguably iconic hit. She truly made the song her own. GA, I'd say, played it a bit safe. A new quasi-rock vibe brought the song into the new millennium, but GA didn't stamp themselves all over it. Despite the change in tone, this comes out a fairly simple cover. Tiffany takes the plus points here.
Looks: GA.
The Winner: Debbie Gibson.
The true mark of any champion is their longevity and Tiffany receded pretty quickly after a brief period of mega stardom. Girls Aloud have scored limited international success but are a massive and endemic hit in the UK. They keep on producing chart-topping material so I'm gonna doff my hat to them - great song, great sound. They've done better, but that's neither here nor there.
3:17
Girls Aloud- I Think We're Alone Nowby jenni3192143,062 views- 1:06
Girls Aloud - I Think Were Alone Now (Movie Video)by ApparentPlayer10,098 views
- 4:32
St Trinians Soundtrack [Chipmunk Version]by FunkiChipmunks23,440 views
- 4:24
Deborah Gibson - M.Y.O.B.by elektrikyouth10,061 views
- 5:48
Hydra Productions featuring Tiffany - Dust Off And Danceby poptoonz7,526 views
- 3:48
Girls Aloud - I Think We're Alone Now (Baubletastic Radio Edit HD)by 2oo8ga2,863 views
- 5:50
Debbie Gibson Foolish Beat (live concert)by chikka1971931,029 views
- 3:15
I Think We're Alone Now Karaoke / Instrumentalby epsonmicrosoft39,777 views
- 3:18
Girls Aloud - I Think We're Alone Now MV (Album Version)by sherbetpictures6,349 views
- 2:20
Tifanii formerly from MTVs Making the Band 3by Desmillion739,076 views
- 5:37
TIFFANY (Live) I Think We're Alone Now - I Am Loveby luckysmusic10,639 views
- 4:04
I Think We're Alone Now Jack (Love Ellie)by tribeHeaven24,006 views
- 3:46
Debbie Gibson - Lost in your eyes (live)by chikka19712,510,199 views
- 3:40
Girls Aloud - I Think We're Alone Now [G-A-Y Performance]by Grant23078328,013 views
- 5:26
Girls Aloud - Sound Of The Underground medleyby UKLadNathan891,488 views
- 3:41
Tiffany - I Think We`re Alone Now in Chileby rzapatav25,474 views
- 0:33
Debbie Gibson Rick Astley Samantha Fox Tiffany Colisée Québec 10 avril 2009by wiwb3,009 views
- 4:15
Girls Aloud - Money (Video)by Chiiiiler34,245 views
- 3:15
Girls Aloud - I Think We're Alone Now - November 2006by TheGirlsAloud8,978 views
- 3:56
I Think We're Alone Now Instrumentalby instrumentals4u26,316 views
tiffany did this much better girls aloud just did a bad remix
kirsten4cee 1 year ago
I like them both.
35HARROW 3 years ago
Debbie did what better? You mean Tiffany? =- 0
edwrd 3 years ago
Tiffany totally rocked "Love Machine" all by herself when it was sung by 4/5 girls, also GA made I think were alone now like a bunch of sorority girls singing at Karaoke...glamour? Tiff was 15! My god give her a break...But if she re-made the video she would totally rock it again...
edwrd 3 years ago
girls aloud ruined this song. they turned it in to some kind of mixed up mess. this song was never ment to be be played this way.debbie did it better. after all ,, she cared about how the song was really supposed to be done.this group tried to turn it in to some kind of dance song but their spaced out echo and slured music turned it into a nosiey bunch of spaced out distortion
60srocknrollband 3 years ago
i agree
ILOVEGA959 3 years ago
I love the Girls Aloud version. I can't stand Tiffany's.
Bo0mbaby 3 years ago 2