Chopin Nocturne in F minor Op.55 No.1
Uploader Comments (xanden85)
Top Comments
-
Hey, overall it was good!
You might want to try taking the Andante section a little slower, and make sure when you are using rubato that it doesn't feel like you are loosing the beat. Maybe play through with a metronome a few times?
(and the bit where it starts going triplets an really a fast, few of the notes in the chords were wrong, so it was in the wrong key)
But i really like the interpretation, its how I would have played it. :D Keep going! Well done (:
-
u need to make sure that u dont play the semi-quavers as triplets. the semi-quaver rhythm is fundamental to the melody and without it the haunting beauty of the actual triplet phrase is lost. I only say this because I was making this same mistake when I first started learning the piece. good luck
All Comments (57)
-
@angelcutie54 "try being more musical" isn't very constructive criticism as it's not descriptive in the least. You should criticize more like boringname05... See? I even criticize critics constructively ;)
-
Too fast ;). But OK ! ;)
-
14 people people don't understand Chopin.
-
really nice...
-
you played some of the notes wrong in the first fast section when the left and right hands are together
-
vids a bit jumpy, but very well played. thanks for posting the vid.
-
Wonderful wonderful wonderful.
How long have you been playing?
-
There's too much movement to the hands, I feel they're flying! Keep steady the hands..Nevertheless, the sound came out very well..
-
Hey, bum notes aside I liked your interpretation out of everything I found on youtube! I like the pulling, dragging feel to it. The more the better! When I hear this, I think of someone being carted off to a gulag. I want more hesitation, more folk-y sounding. I don't like this nocturne sounding very refined. I want more rubato, to the point where it's almost too much. Your piano makes it sound folkish. In fact, I had a dream last night. This piece was in it, but orchestrated grandly.
-
There are some weird naturals in there that shouldn't be.



This, imo, is very well played. I enjoyed it very much :D
Unfortunately, I was clicking back on Opera and accidentally gave it 1 star. My apologies.
thomasspence 1 year ago 2
Glad that you enjoyed it !
No worries, rating is not important !
Thanks to all who have commented !
xanden85 1 year ago
thanks for everyone comments..
oh well.. i am just a amateur .. posted the video just to see what are the responses.. all responses are welcome..
this is defintely my own recording..
thanks..
xanden85 4 years ago