SNSD - "The Boys" Eng Live perf [FANCAM 720p HD] @ SM Live NY (2011.10.23)
Uploader Comments (CoCoGirl886)
Top Comments
-
@Sunnyssi I'm not an anti fan but they lipsynced. If they sing live, Taeyeon will not be able to spin at 2:52. Check the performances on Music Back, Music Core and inkigayo, you will see how she sang that part.
If you are a real SONE you have to accept that. We all know they can sing but for some reasons they didn't sing live in this performance.
-
@takeitx2 yep yep i agree with you. Its not possible to sing every part, and they don't have to.
especially since the effects on these vocals can't be duplicated with real time FX. its on very advanced settings with Octaver , harmonizer and vocoder layering.
We know they can sing live and as long as they did most of it its all good. U know that MJ lipsyncs some of his parts when he's tired? And he's the golden standard.
All Comments (75)
-
@BoaFanMade its obvious they were lip synching why dont you check out 2:52 and then compare it to other performances. and besides they could've had many reasons for not singing live, maybe they needed to rest their vocal chords, perhaps their english isnt cleaned up enough for them to sing live? Im a fan of snsd and i have no problem saying the didnt sing live, mariah carey, celine dion, MJ all lipsync sometimes accept it, dont deny it. It makes it seem some sones are stubborn
-
Jessica
-
Aw I'm dissapointed. I wanted to see how they would do singing live in English.
-
OMG PEOPLE! THEY ARENT LYP SYNCHING BECAUSE THEY CANT BREATHE OR THEIR TIRED!!! ITS BECAUSE ONLY TWO OF THEM CAN SING WITHOUT HEAVY ACCENTS!!! EVER THOUGHT OF THAT??
-
hyoyeon is always in the back and thats annoying T_T i love you hyoyeon noona <3
-
@haveHEARTT That comment wasn't meant for you. oops.
-
My girls are not machines. they work everytime. they need a rest. Taeyeon was sick. so, sometimes they have to lipsync. please don't blame them. I hate SM.
-
you're so luckyy!!!!! ><
Do you plan make a dance cover of this song ? :)
-
Try playing with singing and dancing at the same time. Puffed hard to sing. I think SNSD sing and dance in the best way for the best performance.
-
댄스가수가 노래 전체를 live로 부르는 예는 없다. MJ도 마찬가지였다. 여러분이 직접 춤추면서 노래를 해봐라, 숨이 차서 노래가 불안정해진다. 소녀시대는 공연 중 여러분들에게 최상의 공연을 보여주기 위해 항상 최선을 다하고 있고, 여러분은 그렇게 알고 감상만 하면 되는것이다.
Thanks so much CoCoGirl, do you have BoA?
takeitx2 4 months ago
@takeitx2 You're welcome =]. I actually do have BoA recordings, but for some reason it didn't focus as well. I also had to record parts of her later performances with my phone (hence worse quality) b/c my camera ran out of batteries. So, I'm not sure if I should still upload it seeing how SM uploaded official HQ performance videos... but I'll take a look at my files and see if I have parts that SM left out.
CoCoGirl886 4 months ago