Raoul Koczalski plays Chopin: Nocturne in D flat major
Uploader Comments (Xqwrtz)
Top Comments
-
J'imagine bien Chopin et je l'entends enfin quand quelqu'un le joue ainsi.Aucun doute en effet,mais voici quarante ans que ce que j'écoute "n'est pas du Chopin",mais du vilain maquillage,de la contrefaçon couverte par les trompettes de la Renommée.
Merci pour ce témoignage sublime.
-
Absolument prodigieux ! aucune autre interprétation ne résiste à celle-ci, même je le conçois si Dinu Lipatti est émouvant..car ici on respire le rubato tel que Chopin aurait apprecié. Si vous trouvez que le tempo est "rapide" mettez le métronome indiqué sur le manuscrit vous serez surpris. Beaucoup trop de pièces de Chopin, et surtout les nocturnes, sont jouées lentement c'est une grossière erreur d'interprétation !
All Comments (27)
-
superb
-
All of you who think this is too fast please check Chopin's metronome marking. Mr. Koczalski does not suffer from the erratic tempo fluctuations of some of the slower performances, (Something Chopin hated.) This piece is very agitated and a slow tempo loses this quality. Also the ornaments sound better fast. The subtlety of the harmonies and well defined key groups are also more easily grasped at this tempo. The rondo like structure becomes more clear as well. Stunningly beautiful performance.
-
As bumpy as Paderewski's left hand. Pretty tone, weak brain.
-
Well, anyone can do anything one wants to. Pianists do not have to take a road test. I meant, "I don't like it"... it cheapens Chopin's genius. On later listening, I also find this performance a bit "sweaty" too early. I believe Chopin would have wanted the first statement a bit more elegant rather than with flared nostrils. That said, I generally like his playing.
-
Redécouverte du sublime....ce que la musique devrait toujours être,-une source d'étonnements qui ne cessent pas de se régénérer.
-
Very different -yet superb as well. Bravo! TY.
-
Wonderful
-
Playing at an extremely fast tempo, which is what Liszt said might be acceptable in Mendelssohn, is not really the same as rushing, you know.
to be honest let me say this performance is musically and emotionally the best for my heart. i'm plannig to post more recordings from koczalski, there is a much slower recording of this piece. it also sounds beautyful.
Xqwrtz 3 years ago
becouse he can do that.
Xqwrtz 3 years ago
SUPER!!!
acortot 4 years ago
No doubt, he is fantastic :P
Xqwrtz 4 years ago