Uploader Comments (honeyphan2)
Top Comments
-
@hellifairy - I agree. Tom Hardy did something all the others didn't do- though the others were good, and some very good. But TH depicted all of the facets of Heathcliff in a believable manner- from the loving and sensitive- with Cathy- to the volatile and dangerous to the vengeful and sarcastic to everything else in between. He was what I love in a male character- a complicated individual. Not all bad. Not all good. Multi-faceted like a rough diamond- yet the mystery always remaining alive...
-
Best Heathcliff I have ever seen, he is just like I imagined him, after reading the book when I was 15 years old, and now I am 46.
Video Responses
All Comments (327)
-
Tom Hardy as Heathcliff is unforgettable....sigh.....
-
@Rosamorrable Yes you are right. Ralph Fiennes version did a marvelous job in capturing the atmosphere cos that's the thing that drew me in when I first read the book. Without it the intensity is lost
-
@xane1990 yeah completely agree with you. This version seems to be too lively and bright. It is not faithful to the novel's gothic roots, which is actually the Bronte sisters' signature. I guess the version with ralph fiennes is closer to the novel's dark and heavily foreboding atmosphere. Truly, Emily Bronte who was so outwardly tranquil was surely impetuously passionate inside ... it's almost scary!
-
I LOVE LOVE LOVE this adaption!!
-
For me Laurence Olivie is my Heathcliff but Tom Hardy did very well also don't get me wrong
-
I still love Wuthering Heights with Ralph Fiennes the best.its Kate Bushe's song that make's all of them so good.
-
they remind me of Severus and Lily
-
am i the only one who thinks tom hardy is not hot??
-
this version is too bright and cheerful from the environment to the clothes...they just look wrong. WH is supposed to be dark, depressing and haunting and this one fails in that area. It only manages to focus more on the love between Heathcliff and Cathy something the other versions limited or cut out.
The 2009 version is definatly my favorite! Beautiful video! :) Favorite book too! x
tsewacceber 5 months ago 14
@tsewacceber - thank you! :) And it's my fave version too...
honeyphan2 5 months ago 2
Just saw WH on Netflix, then I found your beautiful video. Love the song, love the movie. So perfect!
bleuxyeux 6 months ago 2
@bleuxyeux - Thank you! :)
honeyphan2 6 months ago
I love this. Great. Thanks for the video :)
Adamc753 6 months ago
@Adamc753 - Thank you!! :)
honeyphan2 6 months ago