Fantastic program!! Congratulations Prof. Ilan Pappe. I'ts amazing to see so many jews atacking the criminal activities of Israel!! veeery good!! It is a very good feeling to see the holocaust survival taking the mask of israeli policies!. the program can not be accused of antisemitism its ridiculous!! No more false myths!! We are breaking the taboo that no one can say nothing against israel!! Israel is not beyond any moral criticismEnough with mainstream propapaganda of CNN and channels alike
This was a horrible show. The audience was loaded with Jewish anti-Zionists. One man asked how a Panel member can speak for Jews. Meanwhile he and Jewish Anti-Zionists in the audience attempted to speak for us, when they represent the tiniest minority of Jews. All I heard was the typical flood of lies and misrepresentations, so many it's impossible to respond to them and most can slip by. And as usual no one mentions Palestinian violence, or asks what changes they need to make for peace.
It is a misquote of Benny Morris Mr Pappe. The Haaretz interview with Benny Morris was over a stark choice he believed Israel had in 1948 to decide: to expel OR be destroyed and for Morris there was no question as to what the choice for Israel was at that time. He has since qualified his view. He does not accept that there was a forced expulsion of all the Arabs that left and that there were a number of reasons.
This is a debate? Alan Hart is supposed to be some sort of mediator? Piffle is what this is.
braktuun 1 year ago
Fantastic program!! Congratulations Prof. Ilan Pappe. I'ts amazing to see so many jews atacking the criminal activities of Israel!! veeery good!! It is a very good feeling to see the holocaust survival taking the mask of israeli policies!. the program can not be accused of antisemitism its ridiculous!! No more false myths!! We are breaking the taboo that no one can say nothing against israel!! Israel is not beyond any moral criticismEnough with mainstream propapaganda of CNN and channels alike
dionisio454 1 year ago
This was a horrible show. The audience was loaded with Jewish anti-Zionists. One man asked how a Panel member can speak for Jews. Meanwhile he and Jewish Anti-Zionists in the audience attempted to speak for us, when they represent the tiniest minority of Jews. All I heard was the typical flood of lies and misrepresentations, so many it's impossible to respond to them and most can slip by. And as usual no one mentions Palestinian violence, or asks what changes they need to make for peace.
IBeatUpThugs 1 year ago
It is a misquote of Benny Morris Mr Pappe. The Haaretz interview with Benny Morris was over a stark choice he believed Israel had in 1948 to decide: to expel OR be destroyed and for Morris there was no question as to what the choice for Israel was at that time. He has since qualified his view. He does not accept that there was a forced expulsion of all the Arabs that left and that there were a number of reasons.
nevskixx 1 year ago