All Types Of Idol Season 9(Top 8 Girls Commentary)

*snooze*

Oh Hi! I am covering thee top 8 gril commentary this week. The girls sang the following:

Katie Stevens- Breakaway(Kelly Clarkson)

Siobhan Magnus- House Of The Rising Sun(The Animals)

Lacey Brown- The Story(Brandi Carlile)

Didi Benami-Rhiannon(Fleetwood Mac)

Paige Miles- Smile(Charlie Chaplin)

Crystal Bowersox-Give Me One Reason(Tracy Chapman)

Lilly Scott- I Fall To Pieces(Patsy Cline)

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• american
• idol
• recap
• 3/10
• semifinals
• top
• girls
• katie
• stevens
• siobhan
• magnus
• lacey
• brown
• katelyn
• epperly
• didi
• benami
• paige
• miles
• crystal
• bowersox
• lilly
• scott

[19DJD]

paige disapointed me she was my favorite despite not being the best singer. she could have been better but blew it i'm sorry to say this but she proly deserves to go home. I would like to see her next week but she did very poorly

[chubbaluvva]

Well, you got your wish!

[jwipe]

I don't believe Paige voice is so great - yes the song choice was bad, but she sang horribly. I've seen no seen of an amazing voice from her this whole competition. And you seriously have to listen to Crystal again. I was completely blown away beginning to end. I thought she brought a LOT to the song. Best performance I've heard yet on the show this season. I think Paige and Katie are going. I really hope you're wrong about Katelyn.

[chubbaluvva]

I have....and then watch Tracy Chapman when she performs it live. I love Crystal and believe she is a frontrunner, but I have heard similiar versions.

And trust me...I WANT to be wrong about Katelyn....but in the slew of blonde hair/indie type of artists this year, I feel she will get lost in the mix. Meanwhile Katie has a fanbase all to herself AND she has the young vote.

[ucns]

OK,, off subject but Cree does not seem to be around..Do you know if she ever got my donation for the winner in idol search last season....Haven't heard from her ...rich

[chubbaluvva]

Shes been having cam issues and stuff going on in her personal life. I'll ask her.

[shukigkato]

Siobhan's performance of "House of The Rising Sun" was the best of the season for me.

1. House Of The Rising Sun

2. Give Me One Reason

3. Rhiannon

[19DJD]

haha yep nice reviews too

[rafz89]

Katie does remind me of Jojo. I worry for her because she's talented but she just doesn't know what to sing.

I thought Paige blew her chances too. I doubt she'll make the top 12.

I think the two getting out tonight are Paige and either Katie Stevens or Katelyn Epperly.

[ucns]

Why did Crystal sit down after singing...I think she is the best...rich