@UmmIbrahim7 Pagans used to drink water, according to this principle, drinking water should also be haram. if something contains indecency or shirk or any other social evil then it can be classed as haram. Birthday celebration has nothing to do with Islam, it is a cultural issue.
That is silly. As he said, some can celebrate birthdays and some may not want to. There is no record of the Nabi [S] celebrating his B-Day. But to say if you do not celebrate him B-Day while you celebrate yours is utter foolishness.
@UmmIbrahim7 Pagans used to drink water, according to this principle, drinking water should also be haram. if something contains indecency or shirk or any other social evil then it can be classed as haram. Birthday celebration has nothing to do with Islam, it is a cultural issue.
naseemarifraja 1 month ago
some say birthdays originate from pagan beliefs, in that case celebrating them is incorrect islamically.
UmmIbrahim7 1 year ago
@XxGirlyxXp
That is silly. As he said, some can celebrate birthdays and some may not want to. There is no record of the Nabi [S] celebrating his B-Day. But to say if you do not celebrate him B-Day while you celebrate yours is utter foolishness.
zoolander12345678910 1 year ago
some people says that if you celebrate your birthday while you are not celebrating
the prophet Muhammed's birthday, then it's haram.
XxGirlyxXp 1 year ago
Assalaam alaykoum, Dr. Zaheer. It appears this video was misnamed.
narjis542003 1 year ago