Mariah Carey vs. Christina Aguilera - The Ultimate Comparison: Episode 1 - Belting

Episode 1 of the new series of videos I'm working on that will compare Mariah and Christina in every way. Stay tuned for new installments :)

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• stardusth2o
• Mariah Carey
• Christina Aguilera
• vocal
• battle
• high
• notes
• belting
• range
• low
• singing
• Celine
• Houston
• Whitney
• Whitney Houston
• Celine Dion

[stardusth2o]

@TheXwatts Xtina's is I Turn To You at the Disney Jam (I think that's what it's called) and Mariah's is Signed, Sealed, Delivered at Obamas inauguration party:)

[stardusth2o]

@sandyzmz 1998 :)

[stardusth2o]

@TroyWannaBE101 Umm, the C5, C#5, D5, and E5 were all from 2008-2009 you dumb bitch.

[stardusth2o]

@ManOfBamboo LMAOOOOO!!! XD

[stardusth2o]

@SuperPianogirl123 LMAO! True!

[LovableNails]

3:49 POWERFUL!!!

[stardusth2o]

@LovableNails YES!!! :D

[Devotedlamb19]

Mariah slays Christina. In-prime, out-of-prime, and forever in the future.

[stardusth2o]

@Devotedlamb19 Exactly. She's 15 years out of her prime, and Mariah can still belt an E5 without strain, something Xtina has never done (or will ever do). Hell, Christina hasn't even belted a C5 without strain.

[QUEHST]

there's something about xtinas voice thats so...pretentious. versus mariahs seems more emotional and honest.

[TheXwatts]

hey, ermm whats the xtina performance at 2:07 and what is the mariah performance at 3:28?

[AJB3]

Prime Mariah's belts were better. I don't think there's been any noticable decline in Christina's voice though, so to say she's past her prime is a bit false.

[Sinned21389]

Was this even needed uh Mariah 2nd best female performer of ALL TIME nuff said

[sandyzmz]

@stardusth2o What year was that when Mariah sang with Aretha because she sounded terrific!!!

[TVmose]

@sandyzmz sorry!! I thought you was the owner of the video LOL. But anyway... the point is that is not right to give strength to these videos, it's an insult to music. Music is what really matters. No comparisons, no vocal battles. That's the point.

[sandyzmz]

@TVmose i dont know what u are talking about.with what shit am i filling up youtube?did i say anything indecent?i just made a reasonable reply to u saying "generation of untalented singers".i just happen to think that even this generation like the previous generations is filled with very talented and wonderful female singers like norah jones,adele,kelly clarkson,alicia keys,jhud,etc.as for mariah and christina,the comparison will never end.and im not the one making these videos.so wats ur point?

[TVmose]

@sandyzmz and by the way... as I said in my first comment, you can't say who's better... people have their own tastes. Every single artist you cited is very talented and has its own peculiarities and defects. There's no need to comparisons. If you think Mariah is better.. or Christina... you should keep it for you. Making videos about it, it's actually a demonstration of how stupid people is. If you love Mariah.. just listen to her... enjoy the music.. dont fill youtube with this shit.