Starfleet at the Battle of Endor
Uploader Comments (Meleth28)
Top Comments
-
Star Trek vs. Star Wars has been a long debate.
But I mean come on! You guys sound immature. Let it drop, it's no big deal. Everyone has their point of view.
All Comments (139)
-
Good work, I thought it was a cool idea to edit in the captains from all of the eras of Star Trek, but why no Ben Sisko or Janeway?
-
LOL... looks like Starfleet came in on the side of the Empire! LOL! Helped crush the rebellion from behind! :p Cool.
-
The epicness is neck deep!!
-
One point I would like to make is this: most of these videos show the Empire or Rebellion vs. the Federation. What about the other races of Star Trek? The Klingons, Romulans, Gorn,Dominion, Borg, Tholians, Andromedans, etc.? Yes, I realize that some of those I mentioned were in this video, but my point is this, why limit these battles to just the Federation?
-
@guardian040 Well, i saw cardassians, romulans, klingons and dominion there too...
But point taken.
-
@sadailinikada86 I guess you didn't get it. This video was not about the Empire. Just mainly Starfleet vs. Rebels. ;)
As for the "suerlaser" - if one is too stupid to use it, it doesn't give one too much advantage. You can just hide behind a planet (like the rebels base moon was) and they fly around that planet instead of just destroying it. LOL ;D
I wouldn't know how the Empire should get to our future milkyway from their long ago far far away galaxy, anyway.
-
Who would win? I would bet on Empire cuz they got tens or hundreds of thousands capital ships, since they span a whole galaxy, and can get from one side to the other very quickly, unlike ST warp that would take well over a hundred years... Regarding weapons or defences, how could you compare them? Empire has no transporters, but has faster ships, no phasers, but has a superlaser that can destroy a planet... too damn diverse, but im betting on Empire only cuz of numbers and superior mobility...
-
Probably how it would go......well done
-
Looks like a nice looking sequence, but would like to see a more "sharpened" one =)
And about those who are still discussion with franchise is better with technical info, guess what? They're teaching Sci-Fi at a uni in London! And guess what? It's not in Sciences! It's in art! You should be evaluating both through the script and the acting and stuff like that, not with the idea of who would win a war!
It's interesting, but the editing could have been a lot better.
jamespiatto 9 months ago 3
@jamespiatto Thank you, finally a comment on the video itself instead of some stupid bullshit about the technical specifications of fictional space ships. Yeah, I know it's not the best editing job in the world, but I made it several years ago in Movie Maker during class. I've learned a lot about editing since then and I've been meaning to get around to making a new, better one, but I can never find the time.
Meleth28 9 months ago