These girls are not playing flat, the song begins relative to an A445hz and migrates to 448hz. The notes that sound flat are at 445 while others are migrating sharp to 448. This is the result of learning intonation off of a pythagorean tuned instrument (piano). Once that is removed, natural instinct reverts back to pure tuning, hence more vibrato and a migration sharp. They think this is their fault, not knowing that all the notes on a piano are tempered slightly out of tune.
You girls are for hire? Really?!? Some of your notes sound a little flat. And if you're using this video to market yourselves, you really need to get either a better camera or a better videographer. If I were to hire you, it would be for that girl on the left.
This is the best version on you tube, it follows the original music, it leaves out what is not written in: such as the lute, organ, or harpsichord; and it is the only version on youtube that captures the contrapunctual nature of the piece, the tempo is good, A is tuned at 445hz, I heard no mistakes as I played along, however the song seems to migrate sharp as it proceeds. The second best version is from voices of music.
@C2Low1 yep its the string /finger problem~ saw it... not the tuning problem tuning is good~ but gt abit mistake :) if nt its perfect they tried their best to cover it^^
Amazing very well played
merineluvzmichael 1 day ago
These girls are not playing flat, the song begins relative to an A445hz and migrates to 448hz. The notes that sound flat are at 445 while others are migrating sharp to 448. This is the result of learning intonation off of a pythagorean tuned instrument (piano). Once that is removed, natural instinct reverts back to pure tuning, hence more vibrato and a migration sharp. They think this is their fault, not knowing that all the notes on a piano are tempered slightly out of tune.
rsjaa 1 week ago
You girls are for hire? Really?!? Some of your notes sound a little flat. And if you're using this video to market yourselves, you really need to get either a better camera or a better videographer. If I were to hire you, it would be for that girl on the left.
MrWhyever 2 weeks ago
@milstein91 it's sound like this right ?
Th3Alfisti 2 weeks ago
Very nice, but you are out of tune, a bit flat. Keep practicing :)
DanielaClapp 2 weeks ago
This is the best version on you tube, it follows the original music, it leaves out what is not written in: such as the lute, organ, or harpsichord; and it is the only version on youtube that captures the contrapunctual nature of the piece, the tempo is good, A is tuned at 445hz, I heard no mistakes as I played along, however the song seems to migrate sharp as it proceeds. The second best version is from voices of music.
rsjaa 3 weeks ago
are u amateurs?
milstein91 1 month ago
@C2Low1 yep its the string /finger problem~ saw it... not the tuning problem tuning is good~ but gt abit mistake :) if nt its perfect they tried their best to cover it^^
guangrong 1 month ago
ph, it's judt captivating
kelpend555 1 month ago
wow that was lovely the harmony the intonation evrything wow amzing THAT WAS VERY PEACEFULL
danny100077 1 month ago