American Idol Season 7- Mariah Carey Week. Part 4

American Idol Season 7- Mariah Carey Week. Par 4
Mariah Carey Mentors the 7 contenders on American Idol season 7
4/15/08
David Cook- Always Be My Baby
David Archuleta- When You Believe
Syesha Mercado- Vanishing
Jason Castro- I Dont Wanna Cry
Brooke White- Hero
Carly Smithson- Without You
Kristy Lee Cook- Forever

Category:

Music

Tags:

• David
• Cook-
• Always
• Be
• My
• Baby
• Archuleta-
• When
• You
• Believe
• Syesha
• Mercado-
• Vanishing
• Jason
• Castro-
• Dont
• Wanna
• Cry
• Brooke
• White-
• Hero
• Carly
• Smithson-
• Without
• Kristy
• Lee
• Forever
• American
• Idol
• Season
• 7-
• Mariah
• Carey
• Week.
• Par

[MrSuperstar08]

So um y did david cook win again??

[marikitna]

@jrr1234567890 wtf

[hulk2008able]

i didin t like

[Hellcome2play]

@marikitna Its a legacy. crappy singers winning the vote miraculously. its sad, that's why i just stopped watching american idol.

[rksu747]

I can say that the arrangement carried david cook in this song. It was so beautiful but it did not hide the fact that his voice sounded lethargic. I loved the arrangement but hated his singing. The judges gave him an unfair pass.

[iiAmitx3]

david made the song so sad... it's supposed to be happy! that's the whole meaning of the song!

[stardusth2o]

David did awful. Totally butchered the song. No one should ever sing MC songs, EVER! SMH!

[karenc33]

I thought David Cook did a terriffic job with this. I liked this arrangement better than the original, and he really turned it into a rock song.

[BlackLightning20101]

@donutstreet Because he went up against Archuleta.

Kristy Lee: I agree with Randy. The best part of the song was the end. In the right hands, Forever could be a country smash. But certainly not in hers and she sure didn't give me chills. Mariah is just too nice LOL...

David Cook: His voice is really rough. Rough timbres have an appeal but his timbre is tired. Especially in his lower register. But I have to give him kudos for turning it into a decent rock cover. If only he had a better voice.

[MusicfaninMO]

On this one, David Cook was terrible.

[the09conradz]

@Navi231 You're welcome and I hope to hear you sing sometime!

[Navi231]

@the09conradz Why, thank you! I was just answering people's questions on why David sucked so bad. And yes, I do have a good ear and I can actually sing, I just haven't had the time to upload anything. I promise, though, that I will. I was actually thinking of covering (and, yes, I know this is a huge risk) My All. Hopefully my baritone voice will love me enough that I can.