Top Comments
All Comments (174)
-
i get the point, and i also noticed how perfect Noels guitar playing trough the years
-
Booze killed many great voices.
Luckily, his studio voice still sounds like the 90s.
-
Is anyone else just not a fan of Zak Starkey's drumming?
-
I don't care what you people say- Liam's voice is fucking brilliant through it all. In fact, it sounds best around the middle of this timeline.
-
main road 96!!!!! the guys voice has decayed over the years but lets face it! point him to a studio and give him a mic and he'll still blow away 95% of the bands today!!!
-
It's called excessive Drink,drugs and cigarettes! :)
-
this song has probly the greatest outro ever!
-
He wore his voice out.
-
liam siempre digo cuadno le empezaron a criticar la voz que ya no tenia 21 años y es obvio que podia sonar distintos de todas maneras siempre canto y sigue cantando expectacular!!!
-
En lo personal me da mucha lata que Liam haya arruinado su voz
-
@cladisla Personally, I prefer Liam because, while both of them gave their all to the band, Liam physically ruined himself to give voice to someone else's words and ideas. IMO Noel, has saved his best work or at least his favourite songs for himself. Liam, despite the fact he was being 'allowed' to sing Noel's songs, had no such prejudice. Every song he was given he delivered as if he meant it personally.
You can debate the fine details of this, but that's all I've got to say.
-
Liam y Noel ..Los hermanos tocados tlvez por un angel..que talento.
-
Liam is the fucking boss!
-
I saw Beady Eye live a couple of months ago and Liams sounded fucking brilliant, he sounds a lot better now than he did for the last 4 or 5 years of Oasis. Some people just like to slag him off because they've got their heads too far up Noels arse. LG Live Forever.
-
Brilliantly put together that,its probably not as good as it was but its still 'flying the flag' and is no way near as bad as some people make out...
-
Liams "new" voice is like his current hair cut.
-
96-98 when liam sounded best
-
@weta123456789 Liam is a guy, stupid
-
@NickLoTurco Opinions though i suppose, I still love his voice now, so either way :)
-
@RobinTaylorJenkins Sounds like he's aged more than 15 years mate, Elton John still sounded great after 30 years. It's a music tragedy that his voice has gone.
-
People are so deluded. I'm a massive Oasis fan, even I can see the whole point of this video (and it's very well done btw) is to show how shit Liam's voice is these days. It's all nasal, embarrassing. Check out Live Forever acoustic on here for MTV, truly awesome performance. To carry on saying Liam "is god" etc is just ignoring the obvious, his voice is crap because he never looked after it. Noel however still has a decent voice and his talent will carry him places Liam can only dream of.
-
@jinjakka :) Yes
-
@belenrossi1 2010 GOD 2011 GOD 2012 GOD
-
Liam's fucking cool!
-
noel is god and always will but liam sings well and always sang her voice was awesome and hopefully no oasis comparison had not separated
belenrossi1 3 months ago 77
it's amazing the way his voice has changed over the years. I think Liam and his voice were the symbol of oasis but sadly it became just a shade of what it was on the past. Noel however, who was the mastermind behind almost all the songs, has shown us that he is a great singer and a complete musician. Personally I like Noel the best, he is no 1994 Liam singing, I know, but he's awesome.
cladisla 2 months ago 11