H. W. Ernst: The Last Rose Of Summer (Kristof Barati, 2002.)
Uploader Comments (likemyviolin)
Top Comments
-
Hillary always sounds like she is trying no to make a mistake, trying to play as clean as possible. That kind of playing is extremelly clean and extremelly boring. Barati, however plays with certain abandon that allows him to serve the music first. I'll take that kind of playing any time. In terms of cleanliness both did a similar work in this piece
-
wow, really good, he´s awesome, his technique really clean.
All Comments (83)
-
@jormanhernandez you forgot André Rieu on your list, and actually he's one of the 3 people who disliked
-
the only people allowed to put "thumb down" are: vengerov, repin, zimermman...i dont think any of the 3 people who put thumb down on this video is one of them
-
@kaikobird i admire your sense of sarcasm :]
-
I seen him in a concert, he played Paganini's 1st violin concerto and this was an addition. He is fantastic, absolutely brilliant. It is really worth listen him live one of the best nowadays! And in Budapest there is the best concert hall in Europe.
-
Amazing...
-
@kaikobird I honestly hope that you are trolling, because if you truly can't hear his gorgeous musicality, I honestly feel sorry for you.
-
good... but I like Midori's better... I like his idea of making it sound like the last sigh of that summer rose but I still like Midori's mourn better.
-
@kaikobird Yes there's no comparison- this is so much better! ;-)
-
very well played! he doesn't take on a robotish expression event for a split-second, BrAvO!
-
the best one is vengerov's version
No-no themontyshow, I can assure you, Kristof is not that type of artist who makes his recordings with 2000 cuts. :)
(About the impossible difficulties: listen to Yulian Sitkovetsky's version of the "Last Rose", in that time, 1951-1955, they couldn't fake audio in that sense.)
likemyviolin 4 years ago