Congratulations, We Regret to Inform You: the college admissions secret
Uploader Comments (rchao)
Top Comments
-
As a former Arcadia High School student, this hit home, great work. Some advice though, it would have helped if you guys interviewed some students from non-top universities who are doing well, have had great achievements, and are happy with how far they've come since getting rejected from these 'top universities'. Sharing these stories would be of much more help to the many students who will be/are enduring rejection from their 'dream schools'.
Video Responses
All Comments (85)
-
horrible video, pretentious etc.
-
I LOVED this so very much.
I thank you. Xx
-
getting into upenn killed me. I never enjoyed high school. but in the end, it feels like it was worth it.
-
@TheDobbyDies well said... its crazy how students who get rejected are heavily impacted, and not many people see it. in my opinion, it shouldn't always be about "who works harder" it's about character and life motives. I see students who work their butts off taking all AP courses and students who do B minus to A average in regular core classes. But ive met smarter kids who take regular classes. If colleges believe rigorous education is how to succeed in life well they are wrong imo
-
Just wonderful
-
@GtarWanaB Opinions are an amazing thing, aren't they? You are calling their video flawed, with a flawed opinion. Someone recommended this video because I'm in the 12th grade and will be graduating in June, and I've been rejected by four colleges this year even though I hold a B through A average and a job. This film is actually very useful for those of us who have no idea why we're getting rejected, and I have no idea where "superstudent" behaviour came from. They all look like normal students.
-
@Greencloud8 Patience is a virtue, my friend. The intro was under 2 minutes.
-
this is stupid because you only interview from the top schools, go interview your community college and see if those students are as happy
-
why do you have so many different people talking. this is irritating next channel.
-
This is very good...
On the one hand commend you guys for making this mini doc about a very relevant topic for high school age kids, especially those in "asian" families. The views presented in this video are flawed however. Giving solely the viewpoints of extremely highly achieving students makes it hard for the "regular" student to relate. Because of this, a doc that could have been inspirational comes across as pretentious and almost encourages "superstudent" behavior, for that i cannot support your viewpoint.
GtarWanaB 6 months ago 27
@GtarWanaB Coming off as pretentious was definitely not our intention, and I am sorry if you got that impression. I know almost all of the interviewees personally, and chose them because I believe they have a valuable story to tell, not just because they go to a top university. I don't know exactly what you mean by "superstudent" behavior, but what we do encourage in this film is for students to pursue their passions, find intellectual curiosity, and have the courage to stay true to themselves.
rchao 6 months ago 27
Part 3 - knowing that undermines the message this video is trying to get across, which is that even individuals who might not have received the highest marks have the chance to get into the universities they want. I question the motive behind the making of this video and whether this is just another gold star on the maker's resume. Lastly, only interviewing individuals from "top" universities alienates your viewers and renders your thesis moot. You're implying happiness only exists there.
HuSkOgS 6 months ago
@HuSkOgS Honestly, Carpus and I made this video because lots of underclassmen ask us for advice, and we always say the same things. So instead of repeating ourselves, we had the idea of getting dozens of people, capture the best advice they can give, and then package it in a neat video to help younger students. Since there would be input from so many people, not only would it be better advice, but it'd be more efficient... and we love filming! And we don't have much to do this summer :P
rchao 6 months ago 4