Bernhard Stavenhagen (1862-1914): Liszt - Hungarian Rhap. 12
Uploader Comments (d60944)
All Comments (11)
-
I don't think it has anything to do with how Liszt would play this work................ Stavenhagen was also terrible and truely inthankful to Liszt.........
I really dislike him as a person........ I had heard this piano roll a long time ago and wanted to listen know that I am much more familiar with the great composer and its sad..........
-
Dear d60944, I've loved this picture for years. I was hoping the Stavenhagen concerto would be cool - but upon hearing this I know a lot more! Thank you so much for this!
-
Nicely done! I also have this midi - the dynamics were automatically created from the roll scan to give an impression only, the levels chosen are appropriate but not precise. A piano roll contains data stating when the piano playing mechanism should start to operate - midi contains note data recording the moment sound is produced from the piano string. This is part of the reason the midi sounds a bit jerky. I hope to post a video with a 100% cleaned up copy shortly. Keep up your good work!!!
-
Very interesting,but as so often,the merits or otherwise of the version,musically,are sabotoge by the jreky adn sotp&start mekankis of teh painorllo,hwoevre ewll is't rpeodudce. Certainly it's tragic he didn't record properly,as ther's evidence of fine playing disguised there! Would it be possible to process it differently,for the rythm problems?The sound is clear, okay, a bit plasticky. Thanks for the enterprising effort.
-
Stavenhagen a indiqué sur le rouleau qu'il avait entendu Liszt jouer ainsi la rhapsodie...
(Wikipédia)
-
thanx a lot!
Alexandros
-
No. He died just a couple of years too early (and if it were only as good as the Brahms recording it would still not tell us much). The best way to try to understand what his playing was like is to listen to his pupils, read their memoirs and read the contemporary descriptions of his playing, and start to learn what 19th century playing was like in general. There are a large number of recordings by 19th century pianists, some of whom even performed with Liszt. Most are on my channel here...
-
what is " piano roll " is this not the real recording >?
Das ist elektronische Musik. Schade, dass man nicht mehr die Orginalton herstellen kann.
branmdo 3 years ago
Ja und nein... es gibt keine "Originalton": bitte lesen die Beschreibung. ;-)
I hope to improve on this electronic rendition in due course though - I am well aware of its shortcomings.
d60944 3 years ago