Et Misericordia - Magnificat (John Rutter)

"Et Misericordia" do Magnificat (John Rutter)

Catedral Nossa Senhora do Desterro
Jundiaí - SP

17 de dezembro de 2006

soprano Solista: Maria Lucia Szot Golebsky

Soprano: Ester Theoto
Mezzo-Soprano: Alline Danttas
Tenor: Edson Carvalho
Barítono: Maurício Martinazzo

Regência: Jan Szot
Piano: Suzana Ferrari

OBS.: Esta é uma gravacao caseira, realizado com um camera digital. Razao pela qual o som infelizmente nao corresponde ao original executado. Gravacao apenas para referencia.

Category:

Music

Tags:

• Et
• Misericordia
• mauricio
• martinazzo
• Magnificat
• John
• Rutter

[JargarForte]

No no no no

there is nothing redeeming about this performance.

It's terrible and I am not sorry.

Not frustrated either.

Yes I played this piece even many times.

I would be bloody embarraced if it sounded like this.

Get real.

Get it off.

It's a disgrace for the composer and his compostion ánd the listener

[lty2k84]

OMG. IF I were RUTTER I would punch every single singer, except the SOLOIST, and the pianist. The conductor needs to get his arms amputated. The rest done tried it and died. I"m sooo pissed, there are no words to describe the pain.

[artofmymusic]

la solista tiene linda voz

[jeravamei]

horrible ..la solista pareciera que esta cantando algo popular...eso gliss que hace son espantosos... y el coro mejor no entrar en detalles

[tacuarembo1973]

totalmente de acuerdo, el tenor estaba muy perdido...jejeje

pero bueno, eso pasa cuando la dificultad de la obra, se subestima...esta area es dificil, tanto para el coro, como la solita... el coro funciona como eco...en muchas partes y aca intenta sonar mas que la solista..bueno...le falta tiempo nada mas..(1 o 2 años diria yo)

bueno, aseguir cantando

[kawaicheng]

What a poor performance... The choir definitely need to learn the notes properly - I dare say there are more notes that is flat than in tune. Horrible when the choir-of-4 comes together. In fact, at some point it seemed to me that they were singing in quarter-tones instead of our normal semitone scale!

I would say that the soloist wasn't much better either - she has a nice voice but no proper technique.

Find the pianist OK though. Seems s/he was trying really hard to keep the choir in tune!

[Naizingi]

the soloist has a nice voice!

[pianistsinger01]

I at them I had not submitted, the soloist has a beautiful voice but needs more technical, more fiato, better impost,support diaphragm and the "choir" needs to learn good work.

[Szmeterlog]

I agree with the people who says its a bad performance.

The solist sound good but the rest....

especially 1:20 and following.. ugh

[jolmus]

I have to agree... this is more an aural insult than anything else.

The soloist is the best part of this. The piano is far from what the orchestra should play here. The male voices simply suck. And there's no balance in the ensemble.

I would not have left the concert, but I would not have enjoyed it either.

[pianistsinger01]

Yo en el lugar de ellos no me hubiera presentado, la solista tiene bella voz pero necesita mucha más tecnica, mas fiato, mejor impostación, y el "coro" necesita aprender bien la obra, el tenor mi sabía lo que estaba cantando.