Scherza infida - Joyce DiDonato LIVE 2007 in Geneva - Ariodante - Handel
Uploader Comments (Gudrun74)
Top Comments
-
Only Handel, it seems, knew how to write such radiantly sad music in a major key. This is a stunningly beautiful rendering of this aria. DiDonato captures all the heartache that is embodied in this music. A tremendous baroque singer.
-
Cette dame est tout simplement géniale.
All Comments (15)
-
Demasiado sobreactuado, es un exceso Joyce. ¡Más naturalidad! Por favor.
-
@vitellia Anne Sofie's version on the Minkowski CD is how I came to love this aria. I love that versions slow and brooding sound.
I was surprised, having only heard that version for so many years (before youtube took off) to discover there were versions of this Aria that sounds like they are 45rpm records being played at the 78rpm setting by mistake.
This aria just does not work AT ALL for me at higher tempo.
Anne Sofie's recording is still way out ahead for me.
-
Ahh this is more like it. I much prefer this Aria slow and brooding, like Minkowski's version.
-
Perhaps the conductor learned his lesson after the sped up con l'ali di costanza. DiDonato's impeccable technique is able to triumph either way!
-
I was there and it was amazing. She is the best with Anne Sophie von Otter (both are very diffent but excellent)!
-
The evidence of Joyce's amazing technique & talent are the fact that she can sing at such a terribly slow tempo! She has a wonderful voice but someone should shoot the person who imposed this tempo-fortunately DiDonato has a voice that keeps the intensity throughout but imagine how brilliant it would have been at Handel's written tempo! Someone needs to go to the library and read D. Wynn Jones thesis, papers research etc on Handel and take a look at the original manuscript!
-
Bravuraaaaaaaa~~~!!!
-
BRAVA! This is AMAZING! Joyce DiDonato is one of my favorite opera singers today, especially her Handel. Ariodante fits her like a glove. This and her Dejanira in Hercules are my two favorites. Is there a complete recording of this opera performance? Thank you SO MUCH for sharing this video with us here on YouTuibe!
Why did you cut it ? Do you know where I can find the whole aria please ? (I mean by Didonato) Thank U very much.
onieshka 2 years ago
The aria is over 12 minutes long and youtube allows only 10 or 11 min. Scherza infida is on JDD's Furore CD. I'll send you all live recordings I have (from Ariodante plus the Furore tour) by mail in a couple of days.
I don't know whether it's a rumour, I've heard DiDonato will RECORD an Ariodante CD. That would be another milestone.
Gudrun74 2 years ago
I find the tempo way too dragging. This got to be the slowest interpretation of this aria ever (12-plus minutes!), easily topping Anne Sofie's recorded version. I also find her voice just way too feminine for this character.
vitellia 2 years ago
The whole aria is 12:40 long. For my ears not too slow, it's probably my fav.
Her most delicate high notes around 9:05, then her pianissimi ... and this from a non-cut and non-manipulated 4 hrs live Ariodante. I'm always stunned by DiDonato's mere physical power, and this combined with most delicate baroque sining incl. real TRILLS. From all singers I've ever heard, nobody comes close in this respect, except Genaux and Bonitatibus.
Gudrun74 2 years ago