@x69Crunchyx 1)if i dont base my judgment on rational thinkong then why should i acknowledge there is a god , because my society said so???? why is it that in quran god ask us to think and not accept without a knowledge!! have you thought about this. haj and so many of things that moslems do are time based simple as that, these days going haj is not that important, haj was advised for unity back then not now since moslems dont get unified by going to haj, but just gain a title haji.
@godseeker11 I never said what Tabatabai said was the truth purely based on the ethos of his self and his credibility but rather due to the actual argument he presents in his book. Well then call all the angels AND jinn your "moshrek" as they bowed down to a bunchof clay. Call me mushrek because i pray to a black cubic house? Call me mushrekbecause i go and chuck stones at some pillar during hajj.
What i am getting at is taht you cant judge this act based onwhat you rationally think is correct
@x69Crunchyx imams (smei gods) in their daily preyers , now you folks consider this old man whome i listen to his sermons which is full of B.S , a man who is connected with your 12 imam who never was born or if he did is entagled in a hole in samer.i am iranian born there in shei family and enviroment belive in these nonsenses .
@x69Crunchyx 1) it because tabatbai said so does not automatically means correct, he did some writting about interssision (shefaat) which is all bunch of nonsense , he had some ok writing about phylosofy , we should measure people's saying including myself with a cogent reason otherwise we will be trapped in person followers (blindly) 2) no matter how you want to say it , shias in general are moshrek , they go and ask these dead folks for their needs , they mention all these so called
@godseeker11 You don't understand, its the people's perception that these things are all that are special in life. Surely they aren't, its the philosophy behind the material. The people in India and what not they know a type of "magic" one that can be taught and manipulated but will always be inferior to any type of karamat which is actually a manipulation of reality.
Seyed Muhammad Husayn Tabatabai in Risalah al-Wilayat explains this in depth. '
@x69Crunchyx Ok you just confimed me, then what is it special aboue people like him ?? except living off of peopl's ignorance or people's tendency to belive in nonsense???
Subhanallah!
noor121212121212 2 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
@x69Crunchyx 1)if i dont base my judgment on rational thinkong then why should i acknowledge there is a god , because my society said so???? why is it that in quran god ask us to think and not accept without a knowledge!! have you thought about this. haj and so many of things that moslems do are time based simple as that, these days going haj is not that important, haj was advised for unity back then not now since moslems dont get unified by going to haj, but just gain a title haji.
godseeker11 3 months ago
@godseeker11 i couldn't understand what you are getting at nor what you said.
x69Crunchyx 3 months ago
@godseeker11 I never said what Tabatabai said was the truth purely based on the ethos of his self and his credibility but rather due to the actual argument he presents in his book. Well then call all the angels AND jinn your "moshrek" as they bowed down to a bunchof clay. Call me mushrek because i pray to a black cubic house? Call me mushrekbecause i go and chuck stones at some pillar during hajj.
What i am getting at is taht you cant judge this act based onwhat you rationally think is correct
x69Crunchyx 3 months ago
@x69Crunchyx so please enough of tales , if you have some cogent reason to back up your claim do so otherwise feel whatever you want to feel.
godseeker11 3 months ago
@x69Crunchyx imams (smei gods) in their daily preyers , now you folks consider this old man whome i listen to his sermons which is full of B.S , a man who is connected with your 12 imam who never was born or if he did is entagled in a hole in samer.i am iranian born there in shei family and enviroment belive in these nonsenses .
godseeker11 3 months ago
@x69Crunchyx 1) it because tabatbai said so does not automatically means correct, he did some writting about interssision (shefaat) which is all bunch of nonsense , he had some ok writing about phylosofy , we should measure people's saying including myself with a cogent reason otherwise we will be trapped in person followers (blindly) 2) no matter how you want to say it , shias in general are moshrek , they go and ask these dead folks for their needs , they mention all these so called
godseeker11 3 months ago
@godseeker11 You don't understand, its the people's perception that these things are all that are special in life. Surely they aren't, its the philosophy behind the material. The people in India and what not they know a type of "magic" one that can be taught and manipulated but will always be inferior to any type of karamat which is actually a manipulation of reality.
Seyed Muhammad Husayn Tabatabai in Risalah al-Wilayat explains this in depth. '
Besides these are all just supplementary acts.
x69Crunchyx 3 months ago
@x69Crunchyx Ok you just confimed me, then what is it special aboue people like him ?? except living off of peopl's ignorance or people's tendency to belive in nonsense???
godseeker11 3 months ago
@Irancolor I think you mean Ali Qadhi Tabatabai who also was the teacher of Allamah Tabatabai
x69Crunchyx 3 months ago