3 Reasons Why Obama's High-Speed Rail Will Go Nowhere Fast
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Sign in to YouTube
Uploaded on Mar 4, 2010
President Barack Obama has pledged $8 billion in tax dollars to build a national network of high-speed rail—trains that can carry passengers at speeds in excess of 150 MPH.
But the Supertrain fantasy was a mistake back in the 1970s, when it gave rise to one of the most expensive—and rotten—TV shows in history. And it's just as much of a wreck in the 21st century for at least three reasons:
1. The lowball costs. CNN estimates that delivering on the plan could cost well over $500 billion and take decades to build, all while failing to cover much of the country at all. Internationally, only two high-speed rail lines have recouped their capital costs and all depend on huge subsidies to stay in operation.
2. The supposed benefits. "We're gonna be taking cars off of congested highways and reducing carbon emissions," says Vice President Joe Biden, an ardent rail booster. But most traffic jams are urban, not inter-city, so high-speed rail between metro areas will have no effect on your daily commute. And when construction costs are factored in, high-speed rail "may yield only marginal net greenhouse gas reductions," say UC-Berkeley researchers.
3. The delusional Amtrak example. Obama and Biden look to Amtrak as precedent, but since its founding in 1971, the nation's passenger rail system has sucked up almost $35 billion in subsidies and, says The Washington Post's Robert J. Samuelson, "a typical trip is subsidized by about $50." About 140 million Americans shlep to work every day, while Amtrak carries just 78,000 passengers. There's no reason to think that high-speed rail will pump up those numbers, though there's every reason to believe its costs will grow and grow.
"Supertrain 2010" was written and produced by Meredith Bragg and Nick Gillespie, who also hosts. Approximately 3 minutes.
For iPod, HD, and audio versions, and for links to the information above, go to http://reason.tv.
And subscribe to Reason.tv's YouTube channel to get automatic notifications when new material goes live!
Standard YouTube License
- 1:49 Obama Replaces Costly High-Speed Rail Plan With High-Speed Bus Planby The Onion Featured 332,478
- 9:07 How to Deal with Cops: Q&A with Steve Silverman of Flex Your Rightsby ReasonTV71,246 views
- 10:06 Wheat, Weed, and ObamaCare: How the Commerce Clause Made Congress All-Powerfulby ReasonTV71,731 views
- 7:01 More Taxes or More Jobs? California Shows We Can't Have Bothby ReasonTV30,916 views
- 9:36 Eugene Volokh on Gun Rights, Free Expression, and the Nanny Stateby ReasonTV13,333 views
- 8:10 Paul Ryan on MSNBC's Hardball with Chris Matthewsby RepPaulRyan173,160 views
- 5:48 Boondoggle in the Motor City: Detroit's Train to Nowhereby ReasonTV156,078 views
- 54 videos Play all High Speed Trainsby ramadurai558
- 4:54 Randal O'Toole discusses High Speed Railby catoinstitutevideo6,259 views
- 8:33 We Are The World 25 For Haiti - Official Videoby wearetheworld131,828,224 views
- 4:47 Will Californians Use High Speed Rail?by ZocaloPublicSquare1,098 views
- 5:54 What We Saw at the Stewart-Colbert Rally to Restore Sanityby ReasonTV217,549 views
- 2:11 Worst. Decade. Ever.by ReasonTV105,301 views
- 5:40 New Hampshire Nannies: Why is the "Live Free or Die" State Banning Fish Pedicures?by ReasonTV36,664 views
- 3:49 KHammer: "'Yes We Can' Means Yes I Can Do Anything I Damn Well Please If I Have the 1 Vote Majority"by PoliJAM43,964 views
- 7:19 High Speed Trains in Europeby Rail Europe11,144 views
- 4:28 Net Neutrality for Dummies: Will the FCC control the Internet?by ReasonTV25,414 views
- 6:00 High Speed Trains Around the Worldby NC3D198,465 views
- 6:01 Treat Me Like a Dog: What Human Health Care Can Learn from Pet Careby ReasonTV27,870 views
- 5:12 The Decline of a Once-Great City: Reason Saves Cleveland Witby ReasonTV34,160 views