Amazinglibertarian response 4 part 2

Part two of my response to Amazinglibertarian, watch the first one too.

Category:

People & Blogs

Tags:

• Atheism
• atheist
• christ
• christian
• christianity
• debate
• refute
• god
• loving
• omnipotent
• omnipresent
• logic
• discuss

[Yewon2001]

Woah highly religious community in Canada? What part of Canada do you live in Alberta?

[BornInAsphodelMeadow]

No, Toronto, but I live in the heavily muslim area.

[AllWorldViews]

"Can God create a stone so large that he himself cant lift it?" Is fundamentally wrong question.

Its like asking: Can God create liquid ice?

[BornInAsphodelMeadow]

It's not a fundamentally wrong question, it's a rhetorical question that illustrates that omnipotence is fundamentally impossible.

[AllWorldViews]

But this question can be dodged like this: God cant create such stone because once stone reach critical size it cease to be stone.

You do know that believers only need the tiniest excuse to dismiss all idea, so stone example no longer works.

[BornInAsphodelMeadow]

I thought that a stone was judged by its makeup, not its size.I think the example still holds.

[MissKatRob]

Hey Asphodel, I just thought id clear up a couple of things. The reason God isnt helping the world is because after the fall of Adam and Eve we became far from God, but if we accept him and build a close relationship with Him we can be close with God once again. And God doesnt view morality differently than us, he is morality. In the absence of God there is no Good or Evil!

[Yewon2001]

I love to see how so many people are ripping off TheAmazingAtheist's name.

[v94j]

geting a beard? :P

[Rosskoflex]

agreed, liquid ice is impossible by definition

[DefenderOfReason]

I just posted a video supporting your position :-)