Lifeboat Scenarios and the Non-Aggression Principle
Loading...
Uploader Comments (XOmniverse)
Video Responses
All Comments (61)
-
An ethical theory must apply to every context. The first test of validity, is logical consistency.
-
Enjoy your day in the sun, don't waste time with objectivism. By the time you have a developed this irrational theory your day in the sun will be over like everyone elses. If you feel the need to convince yourself that your collective wealth is not a matter of military aggression, political and economic manipulation and racial alliances then you are not being honest.
-
DackBev you are an honest man.
Why not just ask: Is it ethical to be unethical? You can't talk your way around it whatever your definition of ethical behaviour is. By the way there is no such thing as objectivism. Why are the "poor countries", for the most part, non-European? Don't you think that this is a way for "white people to rationalize the reasons for their concentration of wealth despite being a minority on earth?"
-
You don't look tough enough to take me on. Don't flatter yourself. You'd be the first to die. If you really believed your philosophy then you better start working out.
7:47
A Rejection of Libertarian Relativismby XOmniverse1,604 views- 2:22
Question about Free Willby XOmniverse1,483 views
- 6:21
Re: The Dumbest Generation?by XOmniverse1,220 views
- 6:25
Agorist Class Theoryby XOmniverse3,143 views
- 3:06
Lifeboat Ethics: What would you do if...by MrCropper2,355 views
- 0:21
The libertarian non-aggression principle...by BryanMorton1,410 views
- 6:12
the non-aggression principle exploredby theinfinityes742 views
- 1:29
Lifeboat Drill on Royal Caribbeanby akcynlyn19,752 views
- 5:43
Rick K. and the Allnighters - Wipe Outby mikeanthrope3,164,330 views
- 3:56
Deftones - Anniversary of an Uninteresting Eventby moiyenna187114,716 views
- 2:41
mother beats child with batby dksouvannakhily3,229,080 views
- 1:42
Episode 1 - Aggression Therapyby healingnetwork90,423 views
- 1:37
Sidmouth Lifeboatby bigozz5641 views
- 9:48
Pro-Life Aggression? You Decideby BeingBob5,295 views
- 9:26
In Defense of Lifeboatsby aaron0883459 views
- 4:09
Trent Lifeboatby barnsleyboyC119,451 views
- 5:55
Inner Aggression "studio/live"by inneraggressiontube10,703 views
- 5:43
Aggression Gewalt Rücksichtnahmeby Urgelsumpf443 views
- 3:25
Tenby Lifeboat Launchby izzyjinx18,964 views
- 11:53
Alter egos and Life-boat scenariosby Luke12000464 views
"The justification for this is that some amount of liberty and property are required for everyone's well being." This is a utilitarian justification for the NAP. There is a deontological justification as well.
LastTrueLiberal 3 years ago
Give me a rational ground for the existence of duty. In other words, why do I have a DUTY to respect the NAP?
XOmniverse 3 years ago
Either you are are aware of the origin of the idea and person that coined the term, Garrett Hardin, or you are not. I suggest you look into it and post an appology.
AfroOntarian 3 years ago
Wikipedia says he was born in 1915. I'm fairly certain that lifeboat scenarios (even if they weren't called that by earlier philosophers) existed and were discussed long before he existed.
XOmniverse 3 years ago
Be honest, "lifeboat theory" obviously was meant to be applied to non-white people. Just say what you mean and don't be a pussy.
AfroOntarian 3 years ago
You're ridiculous. How the hell did you manage to play the race card in response to a video that never mentions race or even has any racist implications?
XOmniverse 3 years ago