Wendy Alexander: bring on Scottish independence referendum 2
Uploader Comments (ScotlandsMessenger)
Video Responses
All Comments (45)
-
@tantawi1992 "Open to all" means including Canadians.
The For Freedom Forums is a political discussion forum and people come with their own political ideas to debate with others, compare approaches, win support, make contact etc.
Therefore I do not have a "group" nor group positions.
In the forums one may support or oppose "sovereigntist" ideas as you wish.
I do not know what you mean by "sovereigntist" but if you would like to explain in the For Freedom Forums you'd be welcome to.
-
@tantawi1992 Canadians have the same head of state as Scots, therefore if we Scots, Canadians, Australians, English etc. would like the freedom to elect our own head of state and the additional freedoms which come with establishing a state which is held accountable and required to respect the constitutional rights of the citizen, say by establishing a Scottish republic, a Canadian republic or a Quebec republic then we all have the same enemy.
Also, the For Freedom Forums is "OPEN TO ALL"
-
@tantawi1992 I tried to message you to invite you to register a username with the For Freedom Forums for robust political debate, inspired by Scots, open to all.
But all I get when clicking on "tantawi1992" is "This channel is not available." So I can't message you.
Anyway the web address is "FIGH. TK"
Please join us.
-
IF Kosovo can have independence than ANyone can and have to strive for independence It has never been easier.
-
WoodlandHunter - Wrong. If you agree with Scottish national independence - democratic freedom for us Scots - then you need to realise that Salmond's 2010 referendum plan is a fraud to deliver independence for the state and to continue the slavery of the Scots under the crown.
The "Right Honourable" Alex Salmond (member of the Queen's Privy Council) is a UNIONIST of the variety which supports the Union of the Crowns, albeit he wants the Scottish state under the Queen but not within the UK.
-
BoxingBadBoy77 - The Queen would never allow the Scottish military to be used against universities with royal charters run by royalist twits so the way to get better run universities and a strong economy is via a republican revolution.
Then the Scottish President of a Scottish republic could give excellent academics like myself an armed escort into universities so then we could start building up the strength of the economy.
The SNP are paddling along shit creek unlike Scottish republicans.
-
BoxingBadBoy77 - The problem is Scottish politicians like Gordon Brown and Alex Salmond have a mutual respect with the universities and leave them to run their own affairs.
It doesn't have to be like that. For example, in the USA, previous presidents have sent federal troops and other officers to force the way in to universities in the South which were banning black students.
People are not banned for their colour in Scottish universities but for daring to exercise academic freedom.
If Scotland was Independent it would be as rich as Norway with all that Oil in the North Sea.
I wonder if Scotland was to become an Independent Nation would it keep the Monarchy like the Irish Free State, or get rid of it like the Irish Republic?
haszo 2 years ago
haszo - It is helpful to distinguish between "Scotland" the land and "the Scots" the nation and people of Scotland.
When the difference is clear then you will see that whilst the Scots CAN become a more independent nation and a less enslaved-by-the-UK nation (by ending the UK's rule over Scotland) NO LAND can become independent, only nations can.
ScotlandsMessenger 2 years ago
haszo - Whilst "Scotland" CANNOT become independent because Scotland is a land and it is not a nation, the Scots CAN INDEED, become an independent nation but ONLY when we Scots elect the a president of a Scottish republic.
If the Queen is head of state, we Scots would be enslaved - told who our head of state was to be.
If the Scottish monarchy is there, we Scots will not be independent. That is why the SNP royalists are liars and really opposed to Scottish national independence.
ScotlandsMessenger 2 years ago