Epydemic2020 - The Happening (To Be About Twenty Minutes Long)
Loading...
79
views
Loading...
Uploader Comments (MaxxPower101)
Video Responses
This video is a response to Theistic Morality Debate: Challenging a Secular Philosophy
see all
All Comments (3)
-
Lol...me and you both release very long videos addressed to epydemic at relatively the same time -_-
so far at 5 minutes in you're saying the same thing ive been saying, i'll watch the rest to see if you mention anything I havnt thought of.
Loading...
Im just going to outline my perception of your main points as I go.
1. The Euthyphro dilemma.
2. We don't know the exact properties of the moral law.
3. Knowledge of morality must come from God + accusation of circularity.
4. Some people incapable of moral knowledge.
5. You think my argument must assume God must exist in order for the argument to be true.
6. Alt explanations for obj morality may exist, they could be like the laws of physics.
Long vid. Did i catch it all?
Epydemic2020 1 year ago
@Epydemic2020 To clarifty;
1. Major objection is the use of the nature of God as a "third" option for the dilemma. It just isn't.
2. Don't know and haven't given an adequate methodology for finding out
3. In essence yes
4. Yes, due to genetic issues beyond their control
5. In the form you present it, yes
6. Yes, further examples being a pantheon of Gods being responsible, morality unintended for humans but another species elsewhere etc.
Only other thing is the issue of theodicy.
MaxxPower101 1 year ago