Pierre Cochereau Improvised Organ Symphony Part 1
Uploader Comments (JFSnail)
All Comments (14)
-
Shnimmuc is a cretin is which has no ears!
-
leexoc I have perfect pitch, plus taste. Refined taste is a rare gift. I do not like bombast and that is what Cochereau improvises along with hundreds of other organist. Stop the personal attacks you are not Cochereau. Cochereau was a hack.
-
@shnimmuc judging by your taste (cummings sax concerto etc.) you have no ear for this music, so of course it all sounds the same to you.
-
I heard Cochereau improvise many times in person, it was always the same canned stuff.
-
Cochereau as no genius. I repeat my remarks, there a many, many organist who do this, including a movement of wrong not fuguing. I am talking about someone inprovising in perfect counterpoint fugue on the equal of Bach. A trio sonata with cannonic imatation. What Cochereau does is easily duplicated
-
And stand by my remarks. There are many organist who do this stuff.
-
@shnimmuc Fugues aren't the only viable form of improvisation. Cochereau could do those as well.
-
@shnimmuc If you have such opinion, than you should listen the "part 2" of this improvised simphony - it is a Fuge. :)
-
This IS GREAT IMPROVISATION. Who is shnimmuc, to critizise such a genius like Cochereau??? Do it yourself better!
Dupré called him a phenomenon without equal, and I doubt, someone is more competent to judge about that...
It's great music!
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is not great improvisation. Great improvisation is where a organist can take a theme and do a text book fugue on it. Anyone can do this stuff.
shnimmuc 2 years ago
Great improvisation also comes from an artist taking a theme and doing with it what they will - if the result is a cohesive piece of music, with thought and structure, then they have succeeded. In this case Cochereau could work wonders. He was that rare thing, a true genius.
His teacher Dupré, didn't call Cochereau 'A phenomenon without equal in the 20th century' for nothing...
JFSnail 2 years ago
My goodness! Where did you get this from? Totally new to me. How many more are still hiding in the archives, I wonder...?
chamade16 2 years ago
I have another two to come....
JFSnail 2 years ago