"The Phantom of Manhattan" in Under 10 Minutes
Uploader Comments (TheaterRaven)
Top Comments
-
Hi, check out my YouTube channel for a full review of this terrible book. Whatever you do, DONT BUY IT! That would only encourage him to do another.
-
Sorry, don't have one handy. I'm busy dropping one on myself. I read an interview ALW did. He said that his version doesn't stick to the book. Well here's hoping anyway.
All Comments (145)
-
I'm a fan of ALW productions (especially his LND and POTO) but I gotta say that this was freaking hilarious!!!!! XD Hey I just have a better sense of humor than most fans. Plus, I really did not like the book anyways. I thought about reading it and then heard it was really bad so I didn't even bother. I'm glad I didnt
-
LMAO oh lord the dr phil moment is priceless lol
-
Awesome:D LOL I LOVED IT! TWO THUMBS WAY UP:)
-
This was priceless! Between this and PhantomReviews I know to just watch these videos and save myself the mental strain of trying to get through the book. :)
-
wow, that was really funny!
-
@PhantomReviews: Don't even put the idea that he might do another one in my mind .-.
-
@TheaterRaven IT BURNS!!!
-
@hazellwood ... I'm sorry........ I didn't see the other comment the dude made....... And I'm not good at detecting sarcasm in real life, let alone through text XD
It's times like this when I thank God for not making Love Never Dies this screwed up. XD
Hahah, love your vids!
TheGreenified 9 months ago 2
@TheGreenified True. I mean, as much as I HATE that demonic spawn, at least it kept out some of the things I hated about "Manhattan", including, but not limited to, making Darius the villain, making Erik's career have nothing to do with music except for the Civil War opera, and, above all, OPENLY dissing Leroux. While LND pisses all over the original novel, at least the prologue of "Love Never Dies" doesn't involve a Leroux-bashing monologue by Madame Giry or something.
TheaterRaven 9 months ago
i was totally prepared for some complete ALW Phantom bashing...but none came! Serisously, I'm one of those "die-hard Andrew Lloyd Webber fans" you spoke of in the video info and none of that was offensive to me. So you might want to try a little bit harder...
swedegirl13 2 years ago
@swedegirl13 I was trying to bash "Phantom of Manhattan", not necessarily ALW or his version of PotO. I put the warning there because there are some CRAZY ALW fanatics out there (the ones who think he's God's gift to musical theater and EVERYTHING he touches turns to gold--if you're one of those, no offense :) ) THOSE fans think even making a light joke is a criminal offense and God forbid you even suggest ALW's a plagiarist.
TheaterRaven 2 years ago