Elly Ney - Beethoven Moonlight Sonata 3. movement (Mondscheinsonate)
Top Comments
All Comments (50)
-
How did you know that Wilhelm Kempff is better than her? I prefer Elly Ney rather than Kempff, because all the harmonic melodies are equally played.. The best example is Kempff playing the 3rd mvt. of Moonlight Sonata, you notice there that the staccato in the 2nd part is not perfectly emphasis.
-
We can really feel what she play
-
... i ... i'v never saw an artist that pssioned... she is realy amazing!!! in the first 2 moovements she almost made me cry ..... it's so amazing! she is perfect!
-
No sorry she is not better than Kempff. But she is till so awesome! Kempff gives it more feeling and is more metronomical than Elly.
Elly experiments with the dynamic range a little more than Kempff. But kempff's performance really takes in the listener.
Elly is not big on pedals and that is a good thing for musicians to reminded of-pedals are really there to enhance and sometimes when you pedal at the wrong places it can throw the music off.
-
she was incredible, but i still prefer the execution of gilels. the deutche grammophon one to be exactly. imho
-
Yeah there´s a lot of fire in this old woman :) xD
-
My god that ending is aboslutley spectacular!
-
Wow this is inspiring, I play piano and I hope that I too play like this when I'm 80.
-
amazing WOW better than Wilhelm K empff
-
Hats off !!
Look at her hands, close to the keys, quiet. No flailing, no useless, wasted movement at all. Glorious artists, who can play into their 80s, even their nineties, with verve and zest. In this, Ney is part of an elite group - Horowitz, Tagliaferro, Saint-Saens, Arthur Rubinstein, Horszowski, Plante. These and others played into advanced old age with panache. Hats off to Mme. Ney!
Noshirm 3 years ago 33
its presto agitato, i think her speed is adequately
listen to gould, he is fast
CyrusMc 2 years ago 13