C.S.A.
Top Comments
All Comments (144)
-
@filrabat I agree. I'm curious to not only know the purpose of this movie but the outcome...as in how it ends.
-
At that point slavery would have been long gone, it was already dieting out, pluss the south is portraied as nazis, we are NOT!!!!
-
Every1 is missing the point. Its all a what if. People are sayin this couldntve happen but we dont know now do we. The whole point is to show the directors and producers ideas about a HUGE what if
-
It's so funny how so many yanks think the civil war was fought over slavery it's was not eaven 2% of the conflict of the war infact more of the union souldures had slaves than rebels not to mention most rebels where agents slavery if you realy want to know the main reason read the articles of the civil war
-
I guess some people dont know what Mockumentary, its not meant to be taken seriously! its mocking not offending
-
Seems like a very pretentious view of Southerners.
-
@filrabat Yes and the makers of the film should have realised it, as the conservative historian character clearly stated that slavery was economically untenable.
-
How about CIS Star Wars What If. That would be more interesting then this!
-
if this was done about blacks people would melt down. Hell you can't tell the truth about blacks without folks melting down.
White folk need to wake up
-
@xXStefan90Xx And your kind of thinking is the reaon why people in the Southern United States will be living in trees two-thousand years from now while the rest of humanity lives on Mars.
I'm a white southerner, and can perfectly see this movie is semi-satire. Even so, I don't like it - not because I find it offensive (I'm man enough to accept the bad with the good), but because I find it simply inaccurate because it assumes slavery would have existed even to this day. I think slavery itself would have probably faded away no later than WW1 due to increased mechanization of farming. I also think a modern CSA would be like modern South Africa. Everyone free but with racial woes.
filrabat 7 months ago 17
There were 4 million slaves living in the south before the Civil War. More than half the population of South Carolina was made up of slaves. In the Declaration of Succession they mentioned slavery over and over again as the cause. They even called the south the slave holding states and the North the non-slave holding states. Southerners need to quit living in denial.
haymaker710 1 year ago 5