Schubert - Der Erlkönig [魔王] (complete version.)
Top Comments
All Comments (457)
-
toll und superrr !
meine Vaterrrrrr , meine Vaterrrrrr !!!
-
wikipedia: Während der 55. Lindauer Psychotherapiewochen 2005 stellte Luise Reddemann die These auf, das Gedicht handele von einem Alptraum eines Opfers sexualisierter Gewalt, das den Täter in zwei Personen zerlege, nämlich in den Vater als „guten Vater“ und den Erlkönig als „bösen Vater“. Dass der Täter in Gestalt des „guten Vaters“ dem Opfer einrede, es bilde sich die Tat nur ein, sei typisch für das Verhalten von Tätern aus dem Nahbereich von Kindern.
-
because he (psychologically) cannot believe to be raped by his father.
-
this song text is worse than Hitler ! Since Erlkings do not exist, except in phantasies of rapists as dust that shall psychologically cover how a father rapes his son to death.
Goethe the German thinker? ... perverted, useless outdated
-
miseducation is worser than no education
-
The favorite song of child rapists !
What a pervert art community !
-
Anybody here can say how he finds or interprets this music! That is how one can learn and judge.
In my view the professional university singer education is dominated by ultra conservative idiots who destruct any lovely or natural expressive human voice and creating inhuman voice monsters with such inhuman exercices. Only similar perverted listeners with repressive ultra conservative education, those of the sort "only what is hard and difficult is art" can stand this.
-
2:57 ff shows that this is a father raping its own son to death. What a terrible story. This is totally pervert ! How can Goethe be handled as famous writer, when he writes and has such dirty thoughts about child abuse in his head. I would refuse to sing such a pervert song. Do you understand the text completely?
-
I performed this song many years ago. Brilliant track. So much passion, and the many characters of the song make it so entertaining. The narrator, the father, the son, the Erlking. Just an amazing piece of music. Beautiful and terrifying.
@Gerstroncio Two things: 1. Are you Schubert? Would you know what he thinks? No. So don't pretend to. 2. You are trying to regulate the internet of all places. It doesn't work. Your farts don't smell that great, so take your head out of your butt and let people enjoy music however they like. It isn't up to the music god, Gerstroncio, to interpret music for others.
Stringy007 7 months ago 48
He's not a singer, he's an actor- look at the different expressions for the different characters! Brilliant...
muulka 7 months ago 34