Top Comments
All Comments (190)
-
@icevalk Well if you keep reading the books Cersei does everything for her children as well. Doesn't mean she's not a crazy lady
-
Luv her voice...could listen to it a whole day :)
-
@TheJboy88 She WAS mad at Ned for a long time, but Ned won her over by doing everything he could to be a good husband since then. Jon never really tried to do anything to win Catelyn's affection (truth be told, anyone who isn't his close friend sees him as cold and sullen, and until the Wall he had entitlement issues) and he acts kind of the way the stereotypical Bastard Usurper acts. We only know he isn't because we see things from his POV.
-
All the hate makes me sad. You cannot expect a woman to treat her husband's bastard the same as her own children.
-
@kakefyll She ignores Jon I don't actually think there's anything wrong with that especially after we've seen how other bastards have been treated. She did have proof her sister a highborn noble women told her that the Lannisters murdered her husband, a childhood friend who is very powerful and has great influence also informed her that the dagger belongs to Tyrion. That's enough proof for medieval society especially when grotesques are seen as the spawn if evil
-
@AnahSkywalker Well, yes. Sort of. The way she treats Jon is rather unfair(in the books at leas), yesyes, I know. He is a product of Ned's infadelity. But that's not Jon's fault. On top of that, she blamed Tyrion with basically no proof. If she hadn't been so dumb, she would have seen that the knife really could have gotten into the hands of pretty much anyone near Tyrion. Not just him. That being said, I don't really hate her. I just dislike these things, but other than that she is ok.
-
@Jalanko13 because you wouldn't be like that if you've lost your whole family?
Honestly not a single Catelyn hater can give a valid reason to hate her
-
i HATE Catelyn in the books! (only read the first 3 so far).
I mean, yea, she has the motivation, but she's SO WHINEY!!!!! "I can't let him be touched by my grief, my grief must not get the best of me, is my little boy lost to me? must handle my grief". It's so annyoing to read that OVER AND OVER again! it's worse than Arya's "Fear cuts deeper than swords"!
-
@TheIrishMail Capturing Tyrion started the war? I have no clue what books/show you have been reading/watching. But it sure as hell isn't this one. The war started because Joff killed Ned. Joff killed Ned because he is a prick and accused Ned of treason. Catelyn wanted Ned to stay at first, until she got a message from her sister saying Cersei killed Jon Arryn. Robb was dead soon after she released Jamie anyways. Jamie was still thought as a prisoner of Robbs army when that deed was going down.
-
Catelyn I almost go mad too, after all of that messing that George RR did to you haha...I don't blame you
Look, she isn't crazy at all. What you need to understand is that each and every character in this series has their motivations for doing what they do. Catelyn Stark's motivations have always revolved around her family. Everything she does is for them. If that makes her a crazy bitch, then you must be real cold
icevalk 2 months ago 47
I love Catelyn!!! She's amazing, strong and very clever. Stop whining about Jon IRS not like she made his life miserable. Compared to other characters (bastards and true borns) Jon's living the life!
AnahSkywalker 1 month ago 29