Why was there no mention of Pyarelal ji who composed this gem along with the Late Laxmikant....I am sure if it was ARR or RDB they would have spoken about the composer for half the show time..
Shankar Mahadevan must not have done improvisation. Thesa old classics are so perfect that even if you add or miss a half note anywhere, it is highly irritating and takes you away from the spirit of that song . Yes, it makes no difference to the compositions of present day composers say Shankar Mahadevan, Salim Merchant or A.R. Rehman, because their compositions are like carpentry and not the genuine creations.
@subhayu1986 brother you have said all the right things. shankar should have known better at rehearsal that this does not do justice. just the fact that he didn't know this, is proof that today's artists don't have the insight of what and how to present at the right moments esp. when lata is watching.
@Learnerforlife100 : your comments doesnt matter to me, you are one of those **** who only now to attack tohers personally, I will suggest you to leave youtube and join gaddafi/kim jong 2, that will be better for you, and fyi, if lata/others are not enjoying, what do you expect them to do? seethe with rage, abuse shankar, and then leave? ofcourse, they will sit and enjoy, they are public figures, dont want to make any controversy.I stick to my comments and people like you have never bothered me!
@subhayu1986 Lata ji who I will go on a limb and say sings a lot better than you & was thoroughly enjoying the song. If Shankar's performance moves an arena full of singers (including Lata, Asha, etc), reputed music directors, and other emerging bollywood singers, who are you to criticize or degrade it? I'm disappointed that you trust those earlike things that you have at the side of head. I am disappointed that I replied to someone who obviously knows jack and understands even less about music
ony violin player do the justice with this song...rest are bakwas..!!
pushpeshkranti 1 day ago
Very Good Singing
MrSkdear 2 weeks ago
awesome
Titan5748 3 weeks ago
Why was there no mention of Pyarelal ji who composed this gem along with the Late Laxmikant....I am sure if it was ARR or RDB they would have spoken about the composer for half the show time..
999timepass 1 month ago
Shankar Mahadevan must not have done improvisation. Thesa old classics are so perfect that even if you add or miss a half note anywhere, it is highly irritating and takes you away from the spirit of that song . Yes, it makes no difference to the compositions of present day composers say Shankar Mahadevan, Salim Merchant or A.R. Rehman, because their compositions are like carpentry and not the genuine creations.
gurmeetmangat 1 month ago 2
@bjornsiborgsi kyon gando teri chut me lun
Samarchohan1994 1 month ago
@bjornsiborgsi : thanks bro, for letting me know that there are people who had the same feeling as I had, after listening to the song. thanks.
subhayu1986 1 month ago
@subhayu1986 brother you have said all the right things. shankar should have known better at rehearsal that this does not do justice. just the fact that he didn't know this, is proof that today's artists don't have the insight of what and how to present at the right moments esp. when lata is watching.
bjornsiborgsi 1 month ago
@Learnerforlife100 : your comments doesnt matter to me, you are one of those **** who only now to attack tohers personally, I will suggest you to leave youtube and join gaddafi/kim jong 2, that will be better for you, and fyi, if lata/others are not enjoying, what do you expect them to do? seethe with rage, abuse shankar, and then leave? ofcourse, they will sit and enjoy, they are public figures, dont want to make any controversy.I stick to my comments and people like you have never bothered me!
subhayu1986 3 months ago
@subhayu1986 Lata ji who I will go on a limb and say sings a lot better than you & was thoroughly enjoying the song. If Shankar's performance moves an arena full of singers (including Lata, Asha, etc), reputed music directors, and other emerging bollywood singers, who are you to criticize or degrade it? I'm disappointed that you trust those earlike things that you have at the side of head. I am disappointed that I replied to someone who obviously knows jack and understands even less about music
Learnerforlife100 3 months ago