Pace Mio Dio- Indra Thomas
Top Comments
All Comments (104)
-
Loads of wobbling, diction and enunciation suffer. Her vowels are really oddly pronounced. A lot of scooping and breaking of the line too.
Explosive B flat though.
-
She is WOBBLY, because she is not a soprano. She is a Mezzo-soprano, just hear her low notes, then when she sings high she sounds so light. Many singers switch from mezzo-soprano to dramatic soprano, because there's more repertoire for dramatic sopranos.
-
I agree with Sjambro!
-
I don't know. Maybe its just me, but I think she's WOBBLY. I could barely distinguish notes, it was so fudged over with vibrato.
-
You probably don't all realize that Indra was in the movie "Driving Miss Daisy".. She sang the solo in the funeral scene -- when the Esther Rolle character had died... Indra had a very mature voice for her age. I do wish someone had lightened her up at some point.. I think they wanted her to be the next Leontyne and darkened her voice up a bit..
-
@kmillard I agree that, in general, there are many I prefer, if only because the voice is less covered, the diction clearer. Thomas has, I suspect, a heavy voice that can only function in very covered mode. I honestly cannot understand more than ... say ... 20% of what she sings. The voice is always too contained and covered for my liking.
-
BRAVA
-
and ms maria callas rip
-
@androgynae i neverr said that Leontyne wasn't a good singer I just think that Thomas is better at this particular aria. As a voice performance major you have too look for the good in things but at the same time we look at the bad...not that we try to be harsh....its just our opinion as to how we critic the bad
-
@bubbahenson Thanks for setting Liwah straight!!!
Liwah...better sharp than flat???? really? i think you need some ear training..cause she is on point every breath, stress, release, she is perfectly in tone..you just have an untrained ear
bubbahenson 1 year ago 7
She has no problem with her high notes. Don't judge bodily movements in singing. Jose Carreras has to move to his tiptoes to get to his high notes. Don't see you judging him!!!1
bashi38 2 years ago 2