Moi dix Mois - Vizard Live (Seth Version)
Uploader Comments (fatedraisondetre)
Top Comments
-
He shouts "rice"! xD
-
the seth version hahaha!!!
All Comments (63)
-
Miossssssss :$ ♥
-
I love the Seth Version...Juka was always like a "little child" for me on stage..so clumsy and Seth fits perfect to "Mana project - Moi dix Mois" ;)
-
I couldn't even finish watching this. Seth's growls and such are terrible. His clean vocals are pretty good but he apart from that I find him just painful to listen to.
-
Seth has a lower tessitura than Juka though they're both tenor but he does better in the grund part. Even their timbres, Seth's does good at some songs but Juka doesn't so we CAN'T say who is better
-
Commentspamming much, but I keep coming up with ideas about the differences between Seth and Juka. XD
Juka doing this song sounds kinda like he's a lone wizard calling up a dark being to do his bidding, but Seth with his vocals sound more like the wizard leader of a big cult, calling his minions. It's different, but I like both. Idk, I just come up with this stuff... XD
-
@fatedraisondetre I've been listening to them a lot over the past month, especially this past week, and I've come to a conclusion. I have no idea which vocalist I like better. I mean, I love both their voices, and I love both versions of this song, I really love how different Seth's screams sound. But why do I really have to choose? I've decided to appreciate them for each their own, and I'm going to check out the stuff Juka does right now. :3
-
dix love \m/
@fatedraisondetre I agree with you, Juka fit this song better then Seth does, but there are also songs that Seth does better then Juka did (Seth was better with Unmoved)
KochoLaLa 9 months ago
@KochoLaLa Personally, I preferred the incomplete version of Unmoved (Juka version) before they decided to make it a screamer. Unmoved isn't really that great of an example as the performance of Juka singing it was the incomplete version, as that song was being written for the Beyond the Gate album which was Seth's debut album.
fatedraisondetre 9 months ago
I don't really see why so many people don't like Seth. I mean, I'm not THAT familiar with all Moi dix mois music, but from what I've heard of Juka and Seth, they're about equal in singing ability. Seth kind of has a rougher voice at times, but that's more a matter of style than skill, right?
sickninjamonkey 9 months ago 2
@sickninjamonkey I don't think that people prefer Juka as a matter of skill, as to style. Personally, that is my own reason for preffering Juka. I loved his over all singing style and tone better than I did Seth. Both are extremely talented, I just prefer Juka's voice to the sound of Moi dix Mois than Seth. Seth fits, but if Seth fits, then Juka was the mold.
fatedraisondetre 9 months ago
@fatedraisondetre Ah, I see. Well, since I've only been listening to them for maybe a month to me it feels the other way around. I love Seths style, and his singing, and to me Jukas doesn't really seem to fit as well to me.
sickninjamonkey 9 months ago
@sickninjamonkey I've been listening to Moi dix Mois for years, and if you listen to all their music, and not just the old stuff, you will notice that Juka fits like a glove. Try listening to Dialogue Symphonie and Mephisto Walts.
fatedraisondetre 9 months ago