Uploaded by CarlySmithsonMusic on Jun 20, 2008
-CHECK OUT CARLY SMITHSON OFFICIAL MYSPACE PAGE AT: http://www.myspace.com/carlysmithsononlyofficialpage -
Carly Smithson performing 'Jesus Christ Superstar' on American Idol Top 6 show.
carly smithson brooke white david cook archuleta jason castro syesha mercado michael johns music song show performance tv andrew lloyd webber musical musicals top 6
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
All Comments (61)
-
It's unfair. Another disaster of American Idol! She sings like a female DAUGHTRY and ended up having same TRAGIC FATE AS HIM BEING ELIMINATED UNFAIRLY! IS THIS WHAT AI IS ALL ABOUT? ELIMINATING ROCKSTARS? WTF!
3 months ago 4
-
@jkcurry87 I agree with everything you said. Except that Syesha's performance was also really good. They shouldn't have been in the bottom two that week. Brooke or Jason should have went home.
-
She was robbed. Vocal powerhouse. That was my first year of watching American Idol, and I couldn't believe she wasn't in the top 2 at least. Usually the criticism seemed biased and totally off from Simon and Randy. Paula was right on.
-
I think Randy and Simon didn't like she was the one who actually appealed to someon else besides 12 yr olds. Amazing performance every week those two beat her down, I think intentionally. Carly you were robbed. David Cook hasn't burned up the charts.....
-
DAMN! She should have WON! :(
-
she's still singing. look up we are the fallen. she's the lead singer. the band is 3 of the former members of evanescence and her vocals kill amy lee's not talent, digitally remasterd voice.
-
I stopped watching Idol when she got voted off that week.... she was the only contestant left who could belt it that hardcore. Stupid Americans... she was amazing, most idiculous upset ever...
-
she rules! youtube should REMOVE THE DISLIKE BUTTON, IT'S USELESS! :))
-
I think she was voted off that week because people with different religions may have found that... not right in their perspective, therefore they stopped voted for her.
9 months ago 4
-
I have always remembered this performance from Carly. It's my favorite of all from her. And hey! This video has received no dislikes! Great job! :)
- 5:59Carly Smithson - Without You - Top 7by CarlySmithsonMusic31,601 views
- 5:48Carly Smithson - Come Together - Top 12by CarlySmithsonMusic28,217 views
- 1:46Carly Smithson - Alone (FULL PERFORMANCE)by CarlySmithsonMusic99,795 views
- 5:29Carly Smithson - Total Eclipse Of The Heart - T...by CarlySmithsonMusic48,001 views
- 3:51Carly Smithson (Bring Me To Life) - American Id...by teensleuthx12,650 views
- 6:42Jesus Christ Superstar (1973) Simon Zealotes-P...by twerqen55,465 views
- 4:16Syesha Mercado - I Will Always Love You America...by wild7horse329,937 views
- 2:12Carly Smithson - Jesus Christ Superstar (Result...by CarlySmithsonMusic7,103 views
- 5:26Carly Smithson - Crazy On You - Top 20by CarlySmithsonMusic14,461 views
- 6:08Carly Smithson - Blackbird - Top 11by CarlySmithsonMusic73,733 views
- 5:41Syesha Mercado, American Idol, Andrew Llyod Web...by nycgraphix83,375 views
- 5:45Carly Smithson - Shadow Of Your Smile - Top 24by CarlySmithsonMusic17,377 views
- 4:35American Idol - Carly Smithson Elimination (4-2...by idolmusic0812,052 views
- 5:53Carly Smithson - Come Together - American Idolby Caliiniiqka18304,853 views
- 4:54Carly Smithson - The Show Must Go On - Top 8by CarlySmithsonMusic17,312 views
- 8:09Carly Smithson on Ellen - Interview and Perform...by EllenLDegeneres62,440 views
- 3:27Carly Smithson - First Auditionby CarlySmithsonMusic297,930 views
- 4:54Carly Smithson - I Drove All Night - Top 16by CarlySmithsonMusic67,185 views
- 4:32Carly Smithson - Here You Come Again - Top 9by CarlySmithsonMusic13,175 views
- 3:47Carly Smithson, Bring Me To Life - Fresnoby livehead16158,851 views
I personally think she did the best this night. AWESOME! I also feel its a disgrace she was voted off this week. I think Brooke or Syesha or Jason should've been outed this week. It turned to popularity this week. Carly didn't really showcase a personality as much as others so she was ousted! AWESOME CARLY!
jkcurry87 3 years ago 53
Carly rules!
cbotten106 2 years ago 29