(5/5) Pacific Lost Evidence Peleliu Episode 5 World War II
Uploader Comments (2bn442RCT)
Top Comments
-
Japs were brave, berserkers.
Video Responses
All Comments (25)
-
You just don't understand how the Japanese where back then. It was a too big disgrace losing a battle so killing themself was the only way to restore their honour. The Americans knews this very well and sometimes gave them the chance to do so. A way of showing the respect to the enemy.
-
@Marzaq87 you know, Im a German, and although as a collective the Germans were the bad guys in this war, there were of course some great commanders in the German military. Even today I can see how the German people as a collective still suffers from the same weakness as back in these days. It often really sickens me. Like many other peoples in the world we Germans lack the balls to value freedom, self-responsibility, and democracy. We WANT to be subordinates, we WANT to remain children.
-
@Skandalos you should try to study more from the japanese side of the story then =) many officers were wise military commanders and you get a better picture of the whole when you read from the perspective of both sides :)
-
@amine0974 The boming on those two cities were nothing less then war crimes. Both sides commited it but the one who wins does not face trial. Atleast they fought honorably through out most of the war.
-
Lets suppose that your logic is true !! what about Hiroshima and Nagasaki ? what about the usage of planes and rockets against an enemy that does not have planes and rockets ?
-
@amine0974 There is no honor in such ways.There is only one way for a soldier to die and thats to die on the face of the battlefield facing the enemy head on.Thats what the japanese did, thats what the US did.
Thats what we all have done.
-
"it is easy to die but difficult to live on"
the first time I hear wise words by a WW2 Japonese.
-
I find the GI giving the Japanese soldier a grenade darkly humourous but also touching, prehaps the GI recognized a trait that he and his enemy shared, the nobility of the human spirit to rise above the deprivations of war under which they both suffered.
-
@virreee94 I agree. What soldier gives his enemy a weapon? Wounded or not
I don't get it !!!
why the US army did not use gaz ? or blockade the jap until they die of thirst and hunger ?
amine0974 3 years ago 2
Thats a good question and theres no easy answer. Politically FDR, Leahy Marshall and a host of other commanders opposed using gas on several grounds. It might sound odd but both objected the use based on moral grounds. They also feared retaliation from Japan in China and Germany might have started using gas on both fronts. With all the nasty weapons available many commanders still viewed gas as too evil. lol. Why don't you research it and get back to me! Thanks
2bn442RCT 3 years ago
Aircraft Carriers cant do everything. Certain Islands with landing strips needed to be taken and secured for further drives towards Japan. The logistical necessity of closely supporting the US forces demanded it. Many areas like Rabaul and other areas where bypassed
2bn442RCT 3 years ago
@2bn442RCT
In hindsight, its kinda obvious what should have happened. Peleliu should have been bypassed since the Marianas operation, closer to the Japanese homeland, we being fought for at this time. If they wanted Peleliu so bad, I should have captured the North island airstrip first, then assault from the south of the main island with a lotta close air support. I woulda stopped at the hills and starved the enemy, using the north river as a barrier between the hillsand the rest of the island.
uncleRayray00 1 year ago
@uncleRayray00 Yes in hindsight I agree.
2bn442RCT 1 year ago