What If
Uploader Comments (Belanna42)
Top Comments
-
I wonder if one of the reasons we love J/C is because of all the adversity these two went through. Their whole relationship was a huge "what if"... which makes everything about them more poignant.
-
That was one of the reasons I loved J/C. I've never quite gotten the C/7 thing - it was just...I dunno... awkward? Sudden? Those two never had the same kind of chemistry that Janeway and Chakotay had.
This is definitely my favorite J/C video, though. I always thought that Janeway thought about it from time to time - especially when they made it to Earth.
All Comments (92)
-
Fantastic video and great song choice :) You did J/C proud.
I noticed some comments talking about the novel "Full Circle" and I'll say that it was one of the most emotional and beautifully written books I've ever read in Star Trek. It's tragic, but it's done well.
-
god this would be such an amazing fic. you basically wrote it for us.
-
I love it, Belanna! I wonder why I didn't find it earlier, lol. A friend just sent me the link. This is exactly the type of JC vid I love the most - it's something that let you dream "What If" and touches your heart.
-
I am absolutely not a J/C shipper, but this video is very good and emotional and the editing is well done!!! The music fits perfectly!
-
@Dreizahn Isabo's Shirt is a good read but you'd have to buy the whole book just for that one story. haha, yep Full Circle is definately my fav. read, no matter how tragic it may be :]
-
@ColdHeartedSoul89 I like it (unexpectedly). It's a good J/C read, by now I can recite pp. 340-347 by heart :)))
I'd like to read Isabo's Shirt as well, thought about buying it after Christmas actually.
-
@Dreizahn you're welcome. how r u enjoying it? do you have Isabo's shirt yet? I have that one in html if you want it, it's also written by Kirsten Beyer and is a good J/C read.
2:28, 3:50...what episodes are those from?
Kimmuryiel 1 year ago
@Kimmuryiel Fair Haven and Night
Belanna42 1 year ago
Beautiful, Amazing, Brilliant
plus you nearly brought me to tears! Brilliant work!!! Throughly loved it! x
jewlz1234567 2 years ago
Thank you so much, I am so glad you enjoyed it :)
Belanna42 2 years ago
beautiful video. by chance, do you know what the name of the episode was when janeway met her spirit guide?
cardsfan2404 2 years ago
Thank you so much, glad you liked it. Yes, the episode is from season 1 I believe, The Cloud :)
Belanna42 2 years ago