Carly Smithson - Without You - American Idol Top 7
Loading...
Link to this comment:
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (28)
-
thumbs u if you think james durbin is better then carly...... just saying ^___^
-
she looks like Prue Haliwell in "Charmed " :D
-
@Matshoppahulle Yes they did, however, Carly did a wonderful job
-
@jdanjd57 Carly makes a good cover.
Mariah Carey,and Harry Nilson ( US no.1) made it better.
-
Now I appreciate Carly even more since I listened to James' version and I love James completely but Carly did amazing. The more I hear others the more I realize what a fantastic job she did on this song.
-
Carly Smithson owns this song when it comes to Idol :]
-
or a song that has too much styling
-
the problem about this girl is her voice is difficult to complement current songs. but vocally she was best vocalist that season
8 months ago 2
-
i can still remember back in 2008, after watching this performance, i said what a poor girl chose a wrong song making a disaster.
- 3:51Carly Smithson (Bring Me To Life) - American Id...by teensleuthx12,650 views
- 3:32American Idol 10 - James Durbin - Without You [...by pinkribbonchic35,586 views
- 2:01James Durbin - Without You - American Idol - Ha...by tampashelley5,412 views
- 2:52Carly Smithson - Aloneby carsmithangel9,826 views
- 5:51Carly Smithson - Without You (4-15-08)by idolmusic0810,681 views
- 1:47Carly Smithson - I drove all nightby irishsweethearttx9,996 views
- 4:54Carly Smithson - The Show Must Go On - Top 8by CarlySmithsonMusic17,198 views
- 2:52Here Comes The Sun - Brooke White (Studio Version)by CarrieFan4Lyfe51,105 views
- 5:37Carly Smithson- Without Youby irishsweethearttx3,806 views
- 2:03Carly Smithson - The Show Must Go On - American...by bonk6564,026 views
- 4:54Carly Smithson - I Drove All Night - Top 16by CarlySmithsonMusic67,001 views
- 1:46Carly Smithson- Come Togetherby BeverleyMitchellLucy50,293 views
- 3:47Carly Smithson, Bring Me To Life - Fresnoby livehead16158,792 views
- 3:10Carly Smithson Auditionby wookiielover100,225 views
- 3:10Carly Smithson - Alone (Hollywood Week)by CarlySmithsonMusic174,674 views
- 1:39Syesha Mercado - Vanishing - American Idol Top 7by bonk6524,147 views
- 5:29Sanshou Fight Tamer in Orlando May-24-2008 TKOby bonk651,951 views
- 4:32American Idol 7 - Top 9 - Carly Smithson - Here...by wookiielover190,494 views
- 10:35Ben Moody & Carly Smithson Interview [AP Live] ...by LightEnchanted691 views
this song is actually a "badfinger" song from 1970, 20 years before mariah did it. harry nillson made it big in 1973, and, 17 years later, mariah did it
osahju914 3 years ago 9
Oh, this was much better than James.
TwisterFlipp95 8 months ago 7