Between Henry - Henry/Anne/Katherine
Uploader Comments (heirofamalfoy)
Top Comments
-
Too bad Katherine's gone from the series :(
All Comments (51)
-
King Henry was a psycho/neurotic idiot even if he was smart and powerful. Most of these woman could not properly conceive probably because of his infidelity. If a man leaves a woman for you, you can be sure you stand to be the next in line to be left by him. She was to young/naive and thought she could change him. He is soo ugly in my eyes even with his power, money and intelligence(cant say looks because he looked like a toad).
-
Anyway why did Catherine have any reason to believe Henry in his promise when he had broken every promise he had ever made her? And why shouldn't she have fought for her daughter's rightful claim instead of letting her put behind Anne's children?
-
A marriage could not be annulled on the grounds of sonlessness. It might be the *reason* why an annulment was sought, but it wouldn't be the *grounds* for it being granted.
Louis and Eleanor's marriage was annulled on the grounds of consanguinity; they were third cousins once removed or something like that (ironically, almost exactly the same affinity by blood that Henry and Catherine shared), so it provided an official excuse to annul their marriage.
-
The cases are diffrent, In Louis and Eleanor's case it was annulled because of the need for a male heir. In Hnery and Catherine's case it would be annulled on the grounds it was INVALID - and if I marriage is invalid ergo it never legally existed the children of that union would be illegitimate
-
Not necessarily.
In cases where a marriage was made in good faith, which was the case with Henry and Katherine, the children could be considered legitimate, even if it was later annulled - for example, when Eleanor of Aquitaine and Louis VII's marriage was annulled, their daughters were declared legitimate.
Had the pope found in favour of Henry, or had Katherine consented to an annulment, Mary could have continued to be recognized as legitimate.
-
Actually in both of those cases Mary would have been deemed illigitamte
-
England would not have become part of Spain
-
Hnery was always a Catholic, he was NEVER Protestant just a reformer when he wanted an annullment
-
Mary knew that she reinstated her as Queen and it was her dying wish to be buried with her - Elizabeth sadly didnt let this happen, which is very sad as they were not allowed to be together in death or in life.
-
She was NOT more worried about her title than Mary! Mary also didnt reliquish her title. Thye both stood true to their faith and rights rather than see eachother, which is terribly sad, but they both understood eachother that they HAD to do this. If she had reliquished her title this would have been the worst thing she could have done for Mary, she loved Mary deeply,
i feel bad for Catherine most,because she didnt do anything wrong she didnt want Mary to be a bastard,so she wouldnt go through with the divorce but henry got a divorce as we all no.I fell bad for Anne too,because she never got to be the memerable mother figure that Catherine got to be,poor Elizabeth barley could remeber her mother.
wanna2h 3 years ago 16
Elizabeth blocked Anne out of her memory as a defence mechanism. She later was able to recall things and I think even reinstated her mother's title as queen (I'm not 100% sure on that one though) so obviously she made a good enough impression on the toddler, even if she was insanely young ^_^
I feel bad for Catherine in some ways, but she was more worried about titles then her daughter in general is what it seemed to me with all Mary's health issues. And that just... bugs me.
heirofamalfoy 3 years ago