红豆词 (Red Bean Poem) - 吴碧霞
Top Comments
All Comments (30)
-
確實有點"西化"了,可能也是先入為主的結果吧~
-
Her singing is perfect, cheers.
-
擴音器開得過大,失去原味.
-
Beautiful Wu Bixia!!
Do you know where would be possible to find the scores for this version of the music?
Thank you very much.
-
Beautiful Wu Bixia!!
Do you know where would be possible to find the scores for this version of the music?
Thank you very much.
-
Her voice and signing are just exemplary!
-
演唱技巧很好,唯獨對歌詞的詮釋仍有未盡善盡美之處。伴奏的確濁
重,無法感受到樂曲的淒楚。 -
I've always loved this song when I heard it on the radio as a child. I can appreciate the lyrics as a grown-up. Thank you for your explanation. I can appreciate it more after reading your comment. I'm not a critic, but I think this lady sings it really well, too.
:-)
-
She is perfect!
-
well done. your voice has traditional Chinesey you did a great job on this song.
Excellent! No it's not Peking opera style, if you know what real Peking opera sounds like. It is a form of the traditional Western classical style which evolved in China to take on certain Eastern characteristics, which may give one the impression of being thin if you are used to hearing someone like Tebaldi or whatever. But it is extremely beautiful, and not thin at all, very fine singing. My grandmother was trained in this technique and it is instantly recognizable. Beautiful.
GermanOperaSinger 2 years ago 10
詞曲皆妙,唱得真好!
伴奏請勿過度使用延音踏瓣, 稍嫌濁重. 再則劉雪庵原作的伴奏已好得無以復加, 刻意賣弄印象樂派編曲技巧猶如將東方古典美女襯墊得豐胸肥臀, 淒楚的原味稍失. 或許這是我過於古板的看法.當然啦! 這首歌從我兒時學會時至今已歷經50寒暑; 太過鍾情也就成了 "除卻巫山不是雲",請見諒!
tushichiao 2 years ago 8