Andrea McArdle You Made Me Love You In Rainbow as Judy Garland

Andrea McArdle as Judy Garland in Rainbow. Restaging of the scene in which Judy sang You Made Me Love You to Clark Gable on the set of Parnell. The song was well received and was then written into Broadway Melody of 1938. Rainbow is well liked among McArdle fans, not so well liked among Judy fans, (personally, I think she can't hold a candle to Judy's performance) but since so many people seem to request this difficult to find film, thought I'd post part of it. The entire film is very dated (interesting to hear Andrea sing Dinah in the 1930's with all the drums and horns and sounds of the 1970's....)

Category:

Entertainment

Tags:

• Rainbow
• Mcardle

[friendsfamilyaccount]

For those of you looking for a complete copy of this movie, I notice some sellers on Ioffer have it available. I have not dealt with any of them; my copy was from Ebay from a few years ago and I transferred it to DVD.

[friendsfamilyaccount]

No, and now I read there is a new film bio soon to be in production starring Ann Hathaway. I really hope they don't do what they did in this film and NOT use Judy's own voice.

[gotmarines]

my child hood fav from garland and i think this is better!

[rileyrossi]

@friendsfamilyaccount if youv'e read anything lately on it - there are signs that Anne is going to sing if the film is made.

[YoliGZ]

I finally found this movie on VHS. I love Andrea's voice especially in this movie... just beautiful.

[MischievousKittie]

Andrea is good, but her Broadway flare isn't close to Judy s and because its not it throws you off.

[sherwoodbreedrough]

this was made the same year i saw a.m. in "annie" at the victoria palace theater in london; she was just amazing, as was the whole cast...incl. the chorus who sang with such elocution that you could actually understand all the words of all the songs. what a great memory. btw, i discovered on that trip that there really are lilac trees in the heart of town!

[OTRNut]

to me she sounds lke every other young kid with a decent enough voice, but there's nothing special in this performance

[mhertz25]

That was thin, devoid of feeling and awful. Just sayin. RIP Judy, the greatest singer of all time.

[TheHeatherEra]

It's good to see Rue in this as well.

[canadianclarke]

she sounds nothing like Judy Garland...its crazy...in a weird way..I mean Andrea can sing but not like Judy could...there will NEVER be another Judy Garland...some can try but it will never be done

[Pie2]

This is the exact problem with this movie. It sparks comparison. Although in reality there is no comparison. Judy is better and could sing circles around anybody... I had to stop this video and go listen to Judy's version of this song and Andrea McArdle got served.