Hugh Jackman singing Soliloquy from Carousel
Top Comments
Video Responses
All Comments (134)
-
@joyandlady its bastard in the original ¬_¬
-
@joyandlady I have sung this song, and while I don't like the language that Hugh Jackman uses in the song, it is what is written in the music. The MacRae version was in a video, and at that time, you would not have seen language on film when aired on tv (I could be very wrong on this, but that is what people have told me through the years).
-
He started making the fists at the end and my mind saw claws extending...
-
He says "bastard" instead of "bully" (3 min)... you don't try to improve upon Hammerstein's lyrics, okay? That, combined with his styled rendition of this song, makes me cling to MacRae's version even more.
-
@tray2022 Actually his voice is closer to dramatic tenor or what they used to call "lazy tenor". The timbre and tone are really not lyric baritone at all. It's far too light with very little baritone richness. Unfortunately it's more like what is popularly called "baritenor" in musical theatre these days - it's just more tenor than baritone.
-
hugh is a lyrical baritone thats why he has a high tone then dramatic baritones but he is deff not a tenor haha
-
Saw his one man show last week and he sang this! It was magical!
-
He's actually a very talented singer. The thing is, he should be singing tenor. All this stuff is too low for his voice to shine, which is why he doesn't have the colors that true baritones do on this song.
-
Little formal voice training? Hugh graduated from WAAPA, Australia's most prestigious musical theatre institution!
-
When you compare this to MacRae or Raitt, PLEASE remember that this was recorded on a hand held device from the audience, so the quality of the recording is poor. As for comparisons, yes Jackman has had little formal voice training, but I find his "conversational" way with a song more enjoyable and memorable. His Billy is cocky, just as he shoud be.
Behold -- The perfect man.
hpfan 7 months ago 12
As good as Jackman is, his voice doesn't have the textures off McRae.
sicon67 1 year ago 8