American Contralto Janet Spencer ~ O don fatale (1911)
Uploader Comments (CurzonRoad)
All Comments (20)
-
WONDERFUL PERFORMANCE!!! Thank you Sir Doug for sharing this wonderful video.
-
Thank you, Doug. Lovely performance. Maya
-
Whatever the original langauge and revisions IMO this is blood and guts Italian music and Stignan and Simionato and the great Frida Leider bear the standards for me. This seems a bit tentative but I am always glad to hear another approach.
I will listen to this singer in other music which you have posted. Now ro the Bolero..
Thanks Doug and reagrds-John
-
Thanks Doug...........I like her hat!!
-
We are so used to the volcanic approach of Italian mezzos like Stignani and Simionato that a more delicate style, more appropriate, after all, to the French opera that this is, suggests itself as rather tame. Yet I feel this music can stand some subtlety and I like this performance, accurate in rhythm and finely tuned as one seldom hears. I wish Spencer, who has a fine voice, had used the original French text.
-
Thank you for the nice music. I liked her hat also.
--------Ellen
-
Janet Spencer reminds me of a fighter who can't land a punch! Nice footwork and a few spills and chills, but she loses me in the clinches and some of the climactic moments fizzle without a strong finish! Like her color, resonance and enunciation! Thank you for posting, Doug. Her photo shows a woman with a lovely face, kind but determined eyes and a disarming cleft in her chin! Nice work!
-
Very nice performance!
She has a good instrument, but for me she sings to "mannered". I want to hear her just let it rip!
MrCafiero 3 months ago
@MrCafiero
Yes, a nice voice and secure execution. Janet Spencer never actually performed in opera, so what we have here is a scaled down concert performance. THANKS!
CurzonRoad 3 months ago