JSBach - Fugue in Dm BWV 948
Top Comments
All Comments (43)
-
AH c est magnifique! L Europe c est quelque chose!
-
@Lequatus a german one.
-
What kind of harpsichord is this?
-
@wcbroccoli I love intellectual snobs.
-
@ijunkie You're confused again. You have the burden of proof. You have yet to come up with any argument that refutes my original comment about the room vs. the harpsichord causing the "so resonant" sound you observed. You either agree with my comment or you don't. Either way, it doesn't matter to me.
-
@ijunkie I'm merely drawing attention to flaws in your arguments. Arguments which are not even relevant my original comment that you disputed with the claim that the harpsichord must be resonant because it's clearly audible. "Resonant" doesn't mean "clearly audible". It means "producing or filled with a deep, full, reverberating sound". I could turn up the volume on a clavichord recording and make that "resonant" (by your definition), too.
-
@ijunkie The clavichord is a counterexample, not an analogy, to your presumption that a soundboard implies a resonant sound. Also, the issue was never whether harpsichords are resonant or have soundboards, but whether this harpsichord is exceptionally resonant ("so resonant"). You can't even get the topic right.
-
@wcbroccoli Neither are false analogies nor quotes out of context.
Clever fugue!
Instrument is lovely.. so resonant :-)
ijunkie 2 years ago 5
It makes sense.
requiemaeturnum 2 years ago 3